Joe’s Pizza Menu – New York, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : New York, NY

Outpost of a longtime family-owned counter-service pizzeria serving classic pies & slices. Based on 3 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Joe’s Pizza 10038

Address:
124 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038

Phone: (212) 267-0860

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 10 AM–3 AM
Wednesday 10 AM–3 AM
Thursday 10 AM–4 AM
Friday 10 AM–5 AM
Saturday 10 AM–5 AM
Sunday 10 AM–3 AM
Monday 10 AM–3 AM

Menu

Pies
Fresh Mozzarella Pie
Eight slices.
$29.00
Fresh Mozzarella Pie With 1 Topping
Eight slices.
$31.00
Fresh Mozzarella Pie With Half Topping
Includes one left half topping.
$30.00
MeatLover
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball.
$33.00
Plain Cheese Pie With 1 Topping $29.00
Plain Cheese Pie With 2 Toppings $31.00
Plain Cheese Pie With 3 Toppings $33.00
Plain Cheese Pie With Half Topping
Includes one left half topping.
$27.00
Plain Cheese Pizza $25.00
Sicilian Square Pie
Eight slices.
$29.00
Sicilian Square Pie With 1 Topping $31.00
Sicilian Square Pie With Half Topping
Eight slices. Includes one left half topping
$30.00
Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion.
$33.00
Veggie Pie $33.00
White Pie
Eight slices.
$29.00
White Pie With 1 Topping
Eight slices.
$31.00
White Pie With Half Topping
Eight slices. Includes one left half topping.
$30.00
Beverages
Imported Soda
Made with real cane sugar.
$3.75
Stewart’s Soda $3.00
Snapple $3.00
Pies
Plain Cheese Pizza $25.00
Plain Cheese Pie With Half Topping
Includes one left half topping.
$27.00
Plain Cheese Pie With 1 Topping $29.00
Plain Cheese Pie With 2 Toppings $31.00
Plain Cheese Pie With 3 Toppings $33.00
Fresh Mozzarella Pie
Eight slices.
$29.00
Fresh Mozzarella Pie With Half Topping
Includes one left half topping.
$30.00
Fresh Mozzarella Pie With 1 Topping
Eight slices.
$31.00
Sicilian Square Pie
Eight slices.
$29.00
Sicilian Square Pie With Half Topping
Eight slices. Includes one left half topping
$30.00
Sicilian Square Pie With 1 Topping $31.00
White Pie
Eight slices.
$29.00
White Pie With Half Topping
Eight slices. Includes one left half topping.
$30.00
White Pie With 1 Topping
Eight slices.
$31.00
Supreme
Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion.
$33.00
MeatLover
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball.
$33.00
Veggie Pie $33.00
Beverages
20 Oz. Soda $3.00
Imported Soda
Made with real cane sugar.
$3.75
Stewart’s Soda $3.00
Snapple $3.00
Salad
Joe’s House Salad (Family)
Feeds 4-5. Iceberg, cucumbers, peppers, black olives, artichokes, tomato, red onion. Served with house dressing.
$29.00
Joe’s House Salad (Individual)
Iceberg, cucumbers, peppers, black olives, artichokes, tomato, red onion. Served with house dressing.
$9.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Suzy Renee aka NinjaCatt
So delicious! The crust was perfectly crispy, slightly chewy, with the most perfect fire roasted flavor. At first glance, you may think the bottom of the crust appears burnt, but it does not have a burnt texture or flavor. It is the smokiness from the type of oven used. And the flavor of the sauce tastes so authentically Italian. Perfect blend of Buffalo mozzarella, with spinach and red sauce on the Spinach slice. And the perfect fresh basil and tomato with mozzarella on the Caprice slice. Just like a taste of Heaven! The most perfect NY pizza I have had so far! Actually the best pizza I have ever had to date, in my entire life!!!!! ‍♀️ .. Also, there was a long line when we went just after dark, but the line moves pretty fast. Very limited indoor seating, so we had to eat on the run. But still worth it to me!

… more

J P Lotzkar
Joe’s is a well known pizza place near the 9/11 memorial that serves several types of decent NYC style pizza by the slice. Lots of celeb pics on the walls. Pick what type you want and they’ll heat it up for you. Best eaten after being heated up. The texture of the dough is pretty good and there’s good seasoning but I found the pizza a bit dry. Not the best pizza I’ve ever had but worth trying if you’re in the area.

… more

Utsav Srivastava
While I’m not usually a pizza fan, the hype around Joe’s pizza in NYC is so massive that even I couldn’t resist its charm. Picture this: Sunday night, Times Square, a line that could rival a blockbuster movie premiere! I thought, “Let’s save the pizza adventure for Monday.” So, down by Wall Street, the pizza magic happened. We went for the classic trio – cheese, spinach, and Mozzarella slices. Oh boy, it was a flavor explosion! Imagine a thin, crispy crust that’s basically a flavor sled for your taste buds. Trust me, this pizza is worth every cheesy bite. Give it a shot, you won’t regret it!

… more

javb2011
I absolutely HATE pizza , but all I could say is WOW! This place was amazing. The guy in the picture, who works the counter, deserves a raise! He fast, efficient, organized, and kept the line moving. Very authentic. Very real. Very NYC!

… more

Rebekka Nett
Looooved the pizza here. The best pizza I had so far. Simple but really good. Fast service and they are all friendly. We ate here 2 during our 3 day visit and I wish we had them in Germany. I will definitely come back again! Pizza ist very delicious and just perfect.

… more

Chris
Delicious and authentic New York style pizza – this place lives up to the hype imo. Gets very busy at night so take out might be your best option.

… more

Will X
I’ve been looking for an opportunity to get pizza in New York City for years. Well, checked off. The line was out the door. Within minutes, we ordered our pizza. It was put in the ovenat that time. By the time we paid, we had our pizza, and the rest is history. Go try them.

… more

Bar Nguyen
Heard so many great reviews about Joe’s so we had to check it out to see if they were true. Just so happened that we were in the area after taking a stroll off Brooklyn Bridge. This review is for the location near the World Trade Center.

… more

T Lewis
Leave NY style pizza to Joe’s. We were in NYC for one week, we tried multiple pizza joints, and Joe’s pizza is hands-down, the best in NYC. It didn’t help that our hotel was a one minute walk away- anytime day or night we’d hop over to Joe’s for a couple slices or a whole pie. We had Joe’s more times than I am willing to admit. If you see a line out the door and wrapped around the sidewalk, don’t turn around. The line does go pretty fast and It’s. Worth. The. Wait. It’s so good that Joe’s made it on our Delta flight back home to the west coast. Put it in the air fryer and bam! A little slice of NYC in San Diego. Thanks Joe for making our NYC trip memorable with some fabulous pizza!

… more

Darren Smith
If you want to learn what NY style pizza is really all about, this is the place. Watching pizza get tossed here is like watching the Mona Lisa get painted by da Vinci… LIVE. The pizza undercarriage is more beautifully leoparded than an actual leopard. The crust is impossibly thin and crispy while still somehow retaining that NY pizza chew. Despite a little char, there is no burnt bitter taste at all. The sauce is plain (where as most NY style pizza have distinct garlic and orgeno flavors), but the simplicity here just works. Yes, you are paying $4 for a plain cheese slice that 20 years ago was probably a buck. And yes, there are decent $1 slices scattered across the island. But… did you see my pic of the undercarriage? Worth it!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions