Based on 527 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
45 Washington Ave, Wheeling, WV 26003
Phone: (304) 242-5400
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
CAROL WILSON
Enjoyed our dinner. We were staying at Ogelbay and a local recommended Greco’s for a good Italian sub. She was right, it was delicious. The meatball sub was delicious also. Heather was our waitress and went out of her way to make sure our dining experience was perfect. We will be back when in the area.
… more
Melody Marlay
When we arrived, they were less than friendly and not very welcoming. When we placed our order, they got it wrong, and we had to wait to get it right. The food was good. I would recommend this for a pizza craving, but don’t expect good service!
… more
Scott H
This used to be a great place with an incredible buffet. Tonight was apparently not the night for that. My wife and I decided to bring the kids over this evening and what a horrible mistake! Should have turned around after waiting around 5 minutes to be seated and the entire time looking at the buffet with maybe 6 pieces of pizza on it. At this point the place wasn’t all that busy either. Finally get seated and let me tell you the waitress was not the most friendly person I’ve encountered. She said go sit there and you can eat, what do you want to drink we have Pepsi, I asked if they had lemonade for the kids she said I’ll have to make some more and walked away, she finally returned and then asked my wife and I what we would like to drink. In the meantime I managed to find 1 piece of pizza for my son and my daughter a little bit of penne pasta. My wife decided to try a salad she did not eat very much said the ranch dressing was runny and tasted watered down. There has been a gentleman standing by the buffet during all of this and my wife decided to get my son some pasta she asked the guy how long he had been waiting on pizza he said oh it’s been a solid 15 minutes. The waitress was “kind” enough to bring us our check before I had eaten anything and my wife’s partially eaten salad, great service there! Now there are more people waiting around the buffet that is still empty. Someone asked our “friendly” waitress as she walked by if there was going to be any more pizza out and she said “yup.” At this point we decided we are leaving, my wife took the bill up and offered to pay for kids buffet and our drinks, to which whoever was working the counter said don’t worry about, I was appreciative of that however we would have gladly paid for the kids and drinks. We left and ordered defelice brothers pizza, which apparently we should have done in the first place. We got our pizza from there and home and I’ll bet those poor people are still standing around the buffet waiting. Absolutely a disaster for a place that used to be a for sure go to bet, not anytime soon, if ever.
… more
klod fone
$19.67 per person tax and drink for the Fri Sat buffet. Good food. Pizza is yummy. Fries+bacon & Mac+cheese pizza . Pasta Service good. Parking is tough. Busy place. Don’t poop here-go elsewhere. Thank God not a vegan rathole. Good family owned Italian restaurant. A1+++++
… more
Leslie Litten
Was very disappointed that lunch buffet had no pizza on the bar. And when they brought it out it was only 1 pan and was gone within seconds since everyone is here for the lunch buffet. They have some sort of pepperoni roll that is cut up that is good in the spaghetti sauce.
… more
Bill Costello
Ordered a 13 inch Michelangelo pizza 12 wings a 2 L of Pepsi last night from this place. All the food was very very bland. The wings had absolutely no taste even with the hot sauce they’re supposed to be in the pizza sauce very blend. The crust was very dense no flavor. I ordered a chicken breast grill just for my little dog. They charge me for an entire chicken sandwich. What I received were pieces of chicken breast sliced, super thin. Sorry guys you need to do better there’s competition out there. I’m sorry to say I won’t be back!
… more
Aleece Beauchamp
My husband and I loved the food (he is a former Sous-chef). He had the buffet and I had the Tour of Greco’s and both the Lasagna and Chicken Parm were delicious.
… more
Paul Czopek
First time going here, figuring we would give it a try. We got there as the buffet rush just ended but the girls restocked the buffet as fast as they could but another rush came but still ran endlessly to restock. Clean tables and wait on everyone. Excellent food and service. We definitely will make the trip back
… more
Angela Hyatt
Have always gotten excellent food here. However, today was a totally different story. Pizza hoagie was not good at all. The bun was not toasted and had a pickle taste and the cheese and pepperoni were not cooked. The pepperoni roll however was hard and burnt.
… more
Mark Voellinger
HORRIBLE how I was treated by the manager on how a mistake was handled. Placed a order for food at 11:30am, at 12:30pm after the order was placed and paid for got a call that they did not have lettuce to make our lunch with that Jebbia’s truck has not come yet that they are going to call them to check status of their arrival. Never got a call back for ETA of order, I called the at 12:38pm which was told Jebbia’s still has not arrived I then asked to be just to be sure “The hot food isn’t already made so that when Jebbia’s does arrive and the salads are made the hot foods do not get here cold” was assured that it was not made already. Finally at 1:30pm the food arrived and missing items I then called back to speak with the manager. Explained to her that 1. we placed a order 2 hours ago and which you had called a hour later to inform of us of the situation, I said for one when I placed the order why was we never told that from the beginning, manager stated “because we didn’t know”, as the manager and staff you KNOW and don’t tell me you don’t know. 2. Explained items are missing manager wanted to argue with me that items was not missing and I then asked how she was going to handle this situation manage did not respond to my question and stated that “we will get those made quickly and get them to you” then hung up on me before I could say anything else. When the food items that were missing did arrive at 1:45pm the food was COLD. Most horrible service ever , food was cold, chicken was more like beef jerky hard, grec roll was hard and cold. This manager was rude and did not handle this situation well at all and should NOT be a manager.
… more
… View more