Based on 661 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
200 Oak Hill Ave, Endicott, NY 13760
Phone: (607) 484-9716
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alex Neil
While I can’t comment on the full menu or indoor atmosphere, the gelati here is a standout. With a diverse selection of Italian ice flavors layered with indulgent frozen custard, it’s a true summer delight. The custard comes in vanilla, chocolate, or a playful twist option, each enhancing the flavor experience. Outdoor seating lets you savor your treat before it melts, a quintessential summer experience. Do note, this spot accepts only cash at the window. For a refreshing and tasty dessert, this place is a top choice.
… more
Sue Timashenka
Joey’s is an excellent restaurant with excellent food. They even added a new upstairs dining area/bar that is a bit more trendy than their more casual pizzeria setting downstairs. Even the garden salad was excellent with the blue cheese crumbles and FRESH romaine lettuce and vegetables, not icky bagged lettuce. No one beats their pizza, and their prices are affordable, too. One person in our party had their pork chop Milanese style and she said it was excellent.
… more
Joe Mariani
Excellent service, friendly atmosphere. Hands down the very best Chicken Marsala in town!!
… more
Dana Sullivan
Unquestionably the best pizza in the Binghamton area. I usually go for the Pizza Bianco without the meat, and it’s just a white pizza, but something about the perfectly cooked crust and the whipped, herby ricotta is very special. The red pizzas I’ve tried have also been really good, my heart just belongs to the Bianco. In my experience the quality has been very consistent over the years. Besides pizza, they also make excellent sandwiches, which I’ll get if I’m going for lunch and don’t feel like dealing with a whole pizza. Their potato salad side has a unique taste from a lot of others I’ve tried – I think it’s just more mustard and maybe a bit of sugar in the dressing but it really makes a difference. Even without considering the quality, the food is very reasonably priced for the amount you get. If I’m really hungry and only getting pizza, I can eat 4/6 slices of a medium, but a medium could definitely feed 2 if you pair it with a salad or something, or if you’re not as hungry. The portions are generous for other entrees.
… more
Kariah Church
This is good ice cream, but we took our family of 5 (3 kids, 5 and under) and we split two gelatos. We asked for an extra cup for our two year old and the server refused to give us an extra empty cup. We paid $10 for two desserts, and they couldn’t give us one extra cup. It is making me reconsider going back even as local because it’s such a hassle for really, what, a .10 cent cup? I’ll give you the ten cents…go easy on families with young kids – we need it.
… more
Candice Silva
This place is so good! We are new to NY and several people had recommended Joeys. It did not disappoint. Can’t wait to work our way through trying everything on the menu.
… more
Linda McKeon
The service was very good. However I got the eggplant Parmigiano and it was very dry. There was no extra sauce on it and somewhat tough. I will definitely come back but would not get it again or recommend the eggplant parm.
… more
Christopher Fucito
Fantastic experience. Was in the area for a tournament and looking for place to eat with family. Stumbled on Joey’s by dumb luck. Best pizza and veal marsala ever. Chicken alfredo amazing. Wait staff very friendly. Highly recommend! Can’t wait to dine here again.
… more
Lisa
I love their soft serve custard! But I was a little disappointed when I ordered this time. I wanted my custard in a cup with extra sprinkles and they refused. They gave me a tiny cup that was the exact same as if I ordered a cone. Leaving no room for extra sprinkles or melting. Not at all what I wanted. I explained to the girl at the window what I was expecting and she again refused and closed the window. Poor customer service
… more
Chris Kaczor
It’s amazing how I’ve passed this place 10,000 times and have never tried it until now. I’ve lived 5 blocks away on the same street as Joey’s for almost 4 years now and I’ve never actually had a sit down meal here. But I will certainly be coming back more often. One time a while back I had their pizza and also a sandwich here and they were very good. But I kinda overlooked the fact that they actually had full dinners here. Well the other day I saw a picture of a meal on Instagram that looked so delicious that I had to ask the person where they were. When they responded with Joey’s I was shocked. So fast forward a few days and my lady and I head here for dinner. And boy they did not disappoint. I had fettuccine alfredo with grilled chicken and my fiance had penne vodka with shrimp. Everything was awesome. If you’re looking for a reasonably priced, really good Italian meal I’d highly recommend Joey’s!
… more
… View more