Straightforward pizzeria chain, also offering casual eats such as chicken wings, subs & salads. Based on 196 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1536 Maysville Ave, Zanesville, OH 43701
Phone: (740) 452-9444
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Adam W Nelson
Personally, I like this pizza place every once in a while. They’re not the best pizza in town nor are they the worst. The guys on the inside selling the pizza are always happy and ready to talk to you. Unfortunately they have no dine in so whatever you get you have to take home. I would say they’re subs or probably some of the best in town but I can’t say the same about the pizza.
… more
Laura Goins
If you want hair and a plastic bread tie in your sub, then by all means, eat here. Make sure not to get mayo, pretty sure they’ve been using expired mayo for a while now. If their subs aren’t burnt then they’re undercooked. I thought maybe it was just the shift we ordered on, but nope. Gotten from them twice now in the day time and it’s just as bad as night if not worse. Dont waste your money here.
… more
Justin L
Four Star is sort of a hit or miss but mostly a hit on their food. It is a place our whole family can agree on so that’s a definite plus. I’d say their food is usually above the big chain level.
… more
Alexsis Schell
As a local, this is any all time favorite. I would definitely choose here over any local chain pizza place.
… more
Kenzi Cronin
Be careful going to four star pizza on Maysville . They charged my card twice resulting in me spending over 100 dollars there and now they are blaming my bank . I contacted my bank and they told me that Four Star most definitely did charge me twice and charged me on different days for different amounts . I’m so mad rn because they refuse to help me so now I have to go back and forth with the bank so they can try to fix an issue they didn’t cause . I wouldn’t have cared if they had been willing to fix there mistake but instead they were rude and unhelpful.
… more
Ace Earthbrother
I just don’t know how a place can call the Italian sub if they don’t put pepperoni on it . You got to pay for an extra topping if you want to go to Italian sub long as you pay for that extra topping it is wonderful is the best Italian sub
… more
David W. Cosgrave
It’s Called Consistently Hot Food . 45 or less delivery and remember to Tip the Delivery Guy/ Gal. 15 to 22 % .
… more
Nick Donaho
Simply put, one of the best pizza places that I have ever had the privilege of eating from.
… more
Andrew Norris
We order from both locations in Zanesville fairly often and I’m never disappointed. Excellent speed on delivery and excellent food quality from what I’ve experienced…. 5 stars for 4 star pizza for sure…. also I got 2 twelve inch Italian subs for free last time because they have a rewards system that gives you points towards free food. Can’t beat it for the money
… more
Linda Crump
I ordered and picked up and it was hot and ready when I got there.
… more
… View more