Based on 41 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
Address:
195 Manorhaven Blvd, Port Washington, NY 11050
Phone: (516) 883-0034
Website: https://www.andyspizzapw.com/
Social Profile: 
Photo Gallery
Reviews
key lime
This was RJs hometown pizza place which closed about 10 years ago. He told me the story of how his father flew back to town just to get the last pizza before they closed. The same family recently reopened Andy’s and we wanted to check it out. We made reservations but didn’t need them the night we were there. It was a holiday weekend and no one seemed to be in town, so great for us. Hannah was our server and we sat outside in the front. She was super friendly and attentive. We didn’t see there was also a really cute seating area out back until we were leaving. We started with fried zucchini and ordered a pizza half plain and half sausage and peppers. NY pizza is the only pizza I have seen where the sausage is slices instead of chunks. I love it like that! The sauce for the zucchini and on the pizza was really delicious, and the crust was perfect. We took half home and it was even better the next day. RJ said it was just as he remembered it.
… more
Dalit Siegal
We had a great time at Andy’s. Very kid friendly. Food, service, and atmosphere were all excellent. The owner and waiters were very understanding when my toddlers were being toddlers, which was refreshing. We’ll definitely be back.
… more
Valerie Tabaroki
This pizza was outstanding. The service was incredible the waiter even sliced up the pizza and put in on my plate. Best pizza I’ve ever had! Definitely recommend if you’re looking for a good pizza place!
… more
William Snider
Everyone There Was Nice. In My Opinion Paying Over Sixteen Dollars For Sausage, Peppers, & Onions Is A Bit Steep. I Know Food Cost And The Price Of Everything Is Way Up.
… more
Katherine Hernandez
The best pizza I have ever try, so fresh and delicious. The seafood dishes were amazing.The service was amazing and the owner made you feel like you are at home. Who ever has been here before, what’s your opinion?
… more
mark fierro
I’ve been coming since a kid.
… more
Jay Long
Had my wife’s baby shower in the back patio. Wonderful. Right across the street from the park and the beach.
… more
Gennaro Fontano
Best pizza in town. It was cooked to perfection and my entire family loved it. The pasta dishes should not be missed, as my wife said they were phenomenal! It tastes like NYC pizza with a perfect blend of sauce to cheese and the sauce is fresh but not sour and the crust is nice and crunchy
… more
Rosaleen Fairtlough
Great place, when they say family-run, they mean it. I mean the brothers cooking. The wife’s waiting. The daughter and brother-in-law behind the bar. I love the food the atmosphere and you can’t beat the price. It’s is the next local you didn’t know you needed till now.!!! Oh I just edited my review and I am just going to say because I love garlic bread, but their garlic bread with cheese is the best ever.!!!!As is all the food.
… more
Hamza Wakani
Out of the many pizza spots in Port Washington, I think this might be the best regular pie. What really sets apart their regular slice is the crust. It’s like a regular slice with a crisp brick oven crust. It’s perfect. Reminds me of Joe’s pizza in Manhattan. Cheese and sauce are both perfect too.
… more
… View more