Caroline’s Cafe Menu – Key West, FL

Type : American restaurant

Location : Key West, FL

American cafe serving po’ boys, conch fritters & the like in a circa-1838 house with outdoor seats. Based on 4 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Caroline's Cafe 33040

Address:
310 Duval St, Key West, FL 33040

Phone: (305) 294-7511

Website: http://carolinescafe.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday 11 AM–11:30 PM
Sunday 11 AM–11:30 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–11:30 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–11:30 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–11:30 PM
Thursday 11 AM–11:30 PM
Friday 11 AM–11:30 PM

Menu

Main Menu
Conch Fritters
Crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, loaded with conch and island spices. Served with cocktail sauce
$12.00
Dolphin Fingers
Fried mahi-mahi with tartar sauce
$15.00
Tex-Mex Rolls
Homemade fried egg rolls filled with spicy chicken, corn, black beans, melted cheese, cilantro, & onion
$14.00
Chicken Wings
Ten wings tossed in mild, medium, hot, or Crazy Lady BBQ. Served with celery & blue cheese
$16.00
Sesame Ahi Tuna
Seared sushi-grade tuna served rare with red chile soy sauce
$16.00
Tomato Lovers’ Bruschetta
Toasted baguette, Roma tomato, garlic, basil, mozzarella, and balsamic vinegar
$11.00
Quesadilla
Cheeses, peppers, onions, tomatoes, and jalapenos in a flour tortilla
$11.00
Peel & Eat Shrimp
Cooked in Caribbean spices, chilled, and served with tangy cocktail sauce ¼ lb. 8 ½ lb
$15.00
Fresh Green Salads
Macon & Bacon
Crispy fried chicken, corn, Vidalia onions, crunchy bacon, maple pecans, romaine lettuce, and Caroline’s homemade ranch dressing
$17.00
Boston Lettuce Wraps
Grilled shrimp or chicken, carrots, coconut curry noodles, bean sprouts, and cucumber salad with peanut and spicy red chile sauces. Boston lettuce for wrapping
$17.00
Caroline’s Salad Deluxe
Turkey, ham, crisp bacon, tomatoes, hard cooked egg, cucumber, cheddar and Jack cheeses, romaine lettuce, and Caroline’s own ranch dressing
$17.00
Bamboozled Salad
Grilled, chilled, sliced chicken breast, wontons, green onions, almonds, mandarin oranges, sesame seeds, and romaine lettuce with Asian vinaigrette
$17.00
The Bittersweet
Endive, spring mix, blue cheese crumbles, candied pecans, tossed with balsamic vinaigrette 13 add chicken or shrimp
$19.00
Yellowfin & Greens
Tuna filet served rare with toasted sesame seeds, baby lettuces, tomatoes, cucumbers, and balsamic vinaigrette
$18.00
Southwestern Chicken Salad
Grilled, chilled, sliced chicken, black beans, corn, tomatoes, tortilla strips, cheddar and jack cheeses, and romaine lettuce with lime cilantro dressing
$17.00
Sandwiches
Cajun Blackened Chicken Sandwich
Blackened chicken with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and spicy mayo
$14.00
Caroline’s Famous Fish Sandwich
Golden brown fried fish with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce on a warm bun
$14.00
Front Street Club
Roast turkey, ham, swiss cheese, crisp bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on multi-grain bread
$14.00
Shrimp Po’ Boy
A generous serving of shrimp, fried to golden brown perfection, served with lettuce, tomato, and remoulade
$17.00
Cuban Mix
Mojo pork, ham, bacon, pickles, and yellow mustard pressed and heated
$15.00
Dolphin Sandwich
(Mahi-Mahi) Grilled and seasoned with lemon, served with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce
$16.00
Shrimp And Bacon Club
Grilled gulf shrimp, bacon, swiss cheese, tomato, lettuce, and tomato basil mayo served on multi-grain bread
$16.00
Rev. Joe’s Burger
The BIGGEST and the BEST, with lettuce, tomato, and onion
$14.00
Caroline’s Favorites
Chicken Broccolini
Sautéed chicken breast, penne pasta, and broccoli in a creamy parmesan sauce
$21.00
Spicy Cajun Jambalaya
Shrimp, chicken, peppers, onions, Andouille sausage, and tomatoes over rice
$24.00
Caribbean Steak
Grilled marinated skirt steak with fried plantains, black beans, and rice
$28.00
Blackened Chicken Pasta
Blackened chicken, bell peppers, and penne pasta in Cajun cream sauce
$21.00
Island Style Roast Pork Bowl
Slow roasted pork, black beans, rice, Crazy Lady BBQ sauce, & plantain garnish
$19.00
Fisherman’s Fresh Catch
Locally caught fresh fish, grilled or blackened and served with rice and broccoli
$28.00
Desserts
Homemade Key Lime Pie $6.00
Cheesecake Of The Day $8.00
The Cookie Monster $9.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ed Nadwodny
If you visit Key West you have to grab a bite to eat at Caroline’s!!!! Staff is extremely friendly. Food is to die for! Full of flavor and plenty to eat on the plate! Great location and prices are great! So come on down to Key West and fill up with some fantastic food!

… more

PopopThePatriot Ford
I recently had a delightful dining experience at Caroline’s Cafe in Key West, Florida. The first thing that caught my attention was the beautiful patio dining area. It was perfect for enjoying the Florida sunshine while savoring my meal. The fact that the restaurant allows dogs made it even better as I was able to bring my furry friend along. The staff even brought over a bowl of water for my pup to enjoy.

… more

Angelo G
Outdoor spot covered by huge umbrellas and cooled with water fans. It’s a small spot with a great atmosphere and great service. We all had the fish sandwich (what they’re known for) and it was humongous and tasty. The conch fritters were some of the best we had in the keys. Definitely a great lunch spot to try if you’re in Key West!

… more

Kent Fink
The wife and I cut the fish sandwich in half, filled us both up , delicious, can’t go wrong the fish sandwich.

… more

John Davis (JD)
My wife and I had a great time at Caroline’s Cafe. We had wings for appetizers and both had Chicken and shrimp jambalaya, which was fantastic! It was so much food, had to take the rest to go as well as a piece of their delicious Keylime pie!

… more

Andrea Vuković
I was pleasantly surprised with the restaurant. When we sat down, we didn’t have high expectations because it was the first restaurant we came across and we were sooo hungry. The food delighted us. Portion size, speed, service, taste – all commendable. The salad was huge, as was the sandwich, and the pasta and paella were full of flavor. If you are looking for a place for a quick lunch in Key West, you have my recommendations.

… more

Jodi R
We ducked in here to get out of a torrential downpour while walking Duval Street. Although we were still seated outside, the umbrellas were large enough to keep us dry. I must say, it was fortuitous that we ducked in here. We shared a pretty good appetizer of Conch Fritters, but our sandwiches were amazing. I had the fish sandwich, which was probably the best I’ve ever had. The batter was light. The fish was very fresh and flaky, the tartar was very different and tasty and the sandwich itself was humongous. I had to break off 2 ends and gave them to my BF, who had ordered the house burger, which was also humongous. It was done just right and included blue cheese and all the fixings. Both were so filling, Neither one of us could eat our side of fries (3 lucky dogs that night). In addition, our server was very attentive and on the ball. If you are on Duval St and looking for a bite, I highly recommend Caroline’s. PS: They had Heinz Ketchup. Always a plus!

… more

E D
My husband had the chicken sandwich and it was sooo good! If I haven’t had eaten, I’d get the same sandwich as well. It was really flavorful and pared well with the key lime drink. We shared a slice of key lime pie and it was really refreshing!

… more

Ayda Pour
We ate lunch there and the atmosphere was great. The food was OK but I didn’t like the fish sandwich. Fish and chips would be my first choice if it was on the menu. The service was OK and the restaurant overall was average for an American style restaurant

… more

Rob H.
We ate in the courtyard during Lobsterfest 2023. It was a fundraiser lobster boil to kick off lobster season in the Keys. Everything was cooked to perfection and entire server, cook and management was spot on and friendly. See photos for food descriptions.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions