NY Pie is proud to serve authentic New York style pizza made with the freshest & highest quality ingredients. Our dough & pizza sauce are prepared fresh daily; each pizza is hand-tossed & baked in a brick oven, resulting in a thin, crispy crust. We’ve planted our Northeastern roots in the South & are excited for you to experience the pizza we grew up eating. With every visit, we strive to give our customers a fun and welcoming experience. From flour to pie, we invite you to fall in love with our pizza. Welcome home!
Based on 938 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
305 Indian Lake Blvd, Hendersonville, TN 37075
Phone: (615) 431-5618
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kimberly Irwin
The pizza was pretty good, garlic knots were ok, but not worth the price point or the atmosphere. People had to stand around waiting for a seat to open in various places throughout the restaurant…just hoping their food wasn’t ready before someone got up to provide a seat to actually eat. The set up is all wrong. There is no waiting area in the front so people actually stood and waited beside tables where others were trying to enjoy their meal. It was chaotic and when asking for a table to be cleaned off (someone finally finished and we saw an open seat) it was rushed, we had to stand in the aisle and wait, and the table was barely cleaned. We had to finish cleaning the table off ourself. It would have been better if we ordered carry out from Dominos and ate in our car. Parking was also not ideal, only one bathroom stall, and the price point is too high for what you get. I would only stop in IF it’s an off time. Maybe you will get friendlier service and be able to eat your pizza in a more peaceful laid back atmosphere. Don’t go out of your way to try it.
… more
Dave Martin
Holy cow!!! This pizza is amazing!!!!! Hands down delicious! The fella that took my order and the fella that cashed me out (possibly the same fella) very nice! Very professional! And did a great job getting my order correct!
… more
Melody Conde
Being from NY, it’s nice to find a restaurant that has pizza that is similar to what we’re used to eating.
… more
Beth
I had never been and my husband suggested we try it. Boy did we absolutely find a gem! We both got a salad and 2 pieces of pizza. If I had known how large the pizza slices were, I would have just ordered one…but the pizza was hot and delicious. I also cannot say enough about the salad. I’m a veggie girl and wow! It was so fresh and topped with amazing assortment of beautiful colors. Tomatoes, croutons, cheese, artichokes and amazing ranch dressing! I hate when places have great salads and runny/thin dressings but you can tell these ppl take pride in their food! The ranch tasted homemade. My husband got a Caesar salad and he said it was fresh and delicious too. We will most definitely be back! The 2 girls behind the counter were really working hard and the gentleman who made our lunch was so kind as we walked by. Wonderful experience!
… more
Todd Voytko
I ordered a large pepperoni calzone and a piece of cheesecake for take out. The calzone was phenomenal! The cheesecake was a joke. It was truly a sliver of cheesecake for $6. I wish that I could post a picture of it. I would have denied it if I would have seen it prior to it being bagged up. This possibly would have been a 5 star review without the cheesecake debacle.
… more
Brian Dennis
Good pie, a little pricey at $22 for a medium specialty, but I don’t mind paying for quality. I especially like the sliced Italian sausage they use, very tasty and far superior to the tasteless rubbery pre-cooked sausage crumbles used at virtually every pizza chain outside of the Midwest (where they make the sausage in-house).
… more
MaryAnn Grib
Good pizza terrible service. Don’t eat in! I ordered a 14 inch pie but the cashier rang up 10 inch which I didn’t realize till I checked on when the pie would be ready (was taking way too long). They corrected it but put my order on the back of the line instead of the front. When a restaurant makes an error they should try to resolve quickly. Waited an hour in total for 1 pizza. Will never dine in there again! These people don’t know how to run a business efficiently plain and simple but they make a good pizza.
… more
Nadia D.
Pizza is good if you like a thin New York style. The restaurant is in need of some TLC and many times it’s hard to find a clean table. Overall it’s decent, but I wouldn’t say it’s the best pizza in the area.
… more
Ashley M
The food was amazing. The in person service was great as well. Although, we had called to place an order and just pick it up but they placed me on hold and never picked back up. When we got there they weren’t very busy and my husband witnessed them answering phones and placing on hold and never going back and answering them. He waited in the store about twenty minutes. The food was really good though.
… more
Wil Mcafee
first time.. it was cool. this second time hell no. pizza tasted ok but took 20 extra min to get it after I called it in 30min ago.
… more
… View more