The Old Bag of Nails Pub – Old Worthington Menu – Worthington, OH

Type : Restaurant

Location : Worthington, OH

The Original Old Bag of Nails. They say imitation is flattery. So when it comes to our original Fish & Chips, we probably ought to be thrilled to death, and we are. Our Award Winning Fish & Chips is the best fish in town – and that’s no fish story. Our scratch kitchen prepares food to order from salmon and shrimp to fresh handmade burgers and fries. We are family friendly with an emphasis on friendly. We treat our guests like they want to be treated – so come on in!

Branch of a local bar chain serving American comfort food & signature battered fish ’n’ chips. Based on 831 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Old Worthington 43085

Address:
663 High St, Worthington, OH 43085

Phone: (614) 436-5552

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–9 PM
Saturday 11 AM–9 PM
Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday 11 AM–9 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Mini Burgs
Gaylords Mini Cheeseburgers
served with white american cheese, mustard, red onion and pickle.
$7.99
Bacon Cheeseburgers
served with white american cheese, bacon, mustard, red onion and pickle.
$7.99
Hot Cheeseburgers
pepper jack cheese, jalapenos and mushrooms.
$7.99
Quesadillas
Spicy Chicken Quesadilla
a crisp flour tortilla filled with grilled chicken, salsa, monterey jack and cheddar cheese.
$7.99
Vegetable Quesadilla
a crisp flour tortilla stuffed with grilled marinated portobellos, salsa, melted monterey jack and cheddar cheese.
$7.99
Sides
Onion Rings
Thin Cut Fries
Steak Fries
Potato Cakes
Sauteed Vegetables
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Fruit Cup
Cole Slaw
Chips
Applesauce
Hushpuppies
Burgers
Gaylords Favorite Burger
smothered in b.b.q. sauce and topped with crisp bacon and cheddar cheese.
$8.99
Pauly Burger
topped with grilled salami, provolone, white american, banana peppers, italian dressing, lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo on a hoagie bun.
$8.99
Blackened Pepper Jack Burger
topped with pepper jack cheese, cajun mayo, lettuce, tomato and onion.
$8.99
Patty Melt
melted swiss and sauteed onion on crisp marble rye bread.
$8.99
Rustic Burger
covered with melted blue cheese, smoked bacon and crisp onion straws.
$8.99
Your Way Burger
have it any way you want; american, swiss, cheddar, pepper jack, blue cheese, sauteed onions, mushrooms, bacon, or jalapenos peppers.
$8.99
Sandwiches
Fish Sandwich
our famous cold water atlantic fish, broiled, blackened or hand battered and fried; served on a hoagie with lettuce, tomato and onion.
$8.99
Philly Cheese Steak
sauteed onions, mushrooms and peppers topped with melted white american.
$8.99
Pub Famous Reuben
lean corned beef on marble rye with sauerkraut, 1000 island and melted swiss cheese.
$8.99
Turkey Reuben
sliced smoked turkey on marble rye with 1000 island dressing, melted swiss cheese and coleslaw.
$8.99
New England Reuben
our famous golden fried fish topped with coleslaw, melted swiss cheese and 1000 island dressing between two slices of crisp marble rye..
$8.99
Your Way Chicken Sandwich
an 8oz chicken breast prepared your way. bbq, buffalo, grilled, blackened or battered and fried. i like mine fried with buffalo sauce, dont you?
$8.99
French Dip
tender sirloin sliced and topped with sauteed onions and melted swiss cheese on a hoagie served with hot au jus.
$8.99
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
crispy buffalo chicken tenders wrapped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and blue cheese dressing in a soft flour tortilla.
$8.99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
grilled chicken breast, parmesan cheese, lettuce, and caesar dressing all wrapped up in a flour tortilla.
$7.99
Chicken Tenders Basket
fried chicken tenders served with crisp onion rings and honey mustard.
$8.99
Grilled Portobello Mushroom Sandwich
giant marinated and grilled portobello mushroom topped with provolone cheese, grilled zucchini and sun dried tomato mayonnaise.
$8.99
Obon Club Sandwich
sliced ham, smoked turkey, bacon, swiss, cheddar, american, lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayo on three slices texas toast.
$8.99
Desserts
Famous House Made Carrot Cake
treat yourself to the best carrot cake you will ever eat. house-made and sliced to order.
$2.99
Homemade Bread Pudding A La Mode $3.99
Fried Snickers $4.99
Pecan Crusted Ice Cream Ball $2.99
Seafood and Steaks
Lemon Crusted Tilapia
freshwater farm-raised white fish filet, broiled or blackened, topped with garlic butter and served with wild rice and a vegetable garnish.
$11.99
Gaylord’s Fish Dinner
freshwater farm-raised white fish filet, broiled or blackened, topped with garlic butter and served with wild rice and a vegetable garnish.
$10.99
Atlantic Salmon
atlantic salmon char-grilled and served with wild rice, a sauteed vegetable garnish and served with dill cream sauce.
$14.99
Seafood Pasta
ettuccine pasta tossed with sauteed shrimp, scallops, mushrooms and garlic in a white wine cream sauce. served with garlic bread.
$11.99
Gaylords Chicken Dinner
an 8oz chicken breast, chargrilled or blackened served with wild rice and vegetables.
$9.99
Gaylord’s All Natural 10oz. Sirloin
simple and to the point, char-grilled steak topped with burnt butter, served with hand-battered onion rings and choice of caesar or house salad.
$13.99
Starters
Mussels And Shrimp
over a pound of mussels with jumbo shrimp, steamed in white wine, butter, spices and servedwith garlic bread.
$11.99
Chicken Nachos
crisp tortilla chips topped with melted cheese, scallions, jalapenos, black beans, salsa, sour cream and grilled chicken.
$8.99
Bacon & Cheddar Potato Skins
potato skins loaded with chopped bacon, melted cheddar cheese, scallions and served with sour cream. you say potato, i say potato too.
$7.99
Chicken Wings
one pound of tender wings & drums, tossed in your choice of buffalo, garlic parmesan or sweet baby ray’s bbq. for some reason, people order a lot of these. maybe thats because it sounds funny. say, hey, lets all get some chicken wings out loud. it sounds funny.
$8.99
Boneless Chicken Wings
white meat chicken served breaded or grilled, tossed in your choice of buffalo, garlic parmesanor sweet baby ray’s bbq.
$8.99
Onion Ring Basket
crispy battered rings served with a horseradish dipping sauce.
$5.99
Beer Battered Pickles
dill spears hand-battered, deep-fried and served with a ranch dipping sauce. you might be asking yourself, what kind of man would batter his pickle? but i cant help myself. ill fry anything!
$6.99
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
a creamy mix of sauteed spinach and chopped artichokes accompanied by crisp corn tortilla chips.
$7.99
Black Bean Dip
home cooked black beans and fresh salsa mixed together then topped with shredded cheese and served with crispy flour tortilla chips.
$7.99
Hand Battered Mushrooms
fresh button mushrooms battered, deep-fried and served with a horseradish dipping sauce.
$7.99
Potato Cakes
shredded potato pancakes served bite sized with applesauce and sour cream.
$6.99
Soups and Salads
French Onion Soup
always great!!!
$4.99
House-Made New England Clam Chowder $3.99
Tomato Basil Soup $4.99
Soup Of The Day
a delicious daily creation if you don’t order it, it will be the soup of tomorrow.
$3.99
The Pride Of The Pub Spinach Salad
fresh spinach topped with grilled marinated portobello mushrooms, chunky blue cheese, crispy onion straws, blackened cajun scallops or shrimp and finished with a hot bacon vinaigrette
$10.99
The Wedge Salad
an iceberg wedge with blue cheese dressing, bacon, tomato, egg, red onion and croutons.
$6.99
Chicken Cobb Salad
a large bed of lettuce topped with charbroiled chicken, tomato, diced eggs, feta cheese, bacon and marinated onions.
$9.99
Greek Salad
fresh greens tossed in homemade greek dressing and topped with marinated onions, tomatoes, feta cheese, kalamata olives and banana peppers.
$7.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Eric Ebron
Wonderful visit! It had been 16 years since I last visited this place, and they did not disappoint! I mentioned to my wife that they had the 2nd best fish sandwich I ever ate… still an excellent sandwich (highly recommend)!!

… more

Alex Van Gulijk
So, this hands down is my favorite OBON. I had hit/miss experiences at other locations, but my friend recommended the Worthington location for their service. And whoa, the food was just perfect and tasty, the service is very community oriented, and for such a small ‘hole in the wall’ it was really clean and organized, even after a long day. This will be a new go to spot for me!

… more

High Class
The food was AMAZZZZZING!! Great fish! Both the spicy and regular beer battered was really good….quick service and great beer friendly staff and customers

… more

Dan Mitchell
Wow, what exciting history to learn about while enjoying the best fish and chips in the Columbus region. The staff team is super friendly and eager to please the hungry patrons whether it’s great food selections or adult beverages. The establishment is very clean and well organized with pleasant decor throughout. I can’t wait to return soon and enjoy another great selection from their diverse menu selections.

… more

Andrew Pitonyak
I popped in for dinner with the friend about 7:00 p.m. Saturday night. There are lots of tables and we’re not overly busy for food service.

… more

Tandra DeMarcus
Amazing! Love the food and staff.

… more

PE Shearer
Was scheduled to work a few miles from this location, perfect place to stop before starting at customer’s site. My brother-in-law recommended the Worthington location and a coworker had been to the same one and gave a good recommendation as well. The fish and chips (Eddie style) was absolutely awesome! Next time will try something else… maybe. Great food, great service.

… more

John Contreras
Great atmosphere and super friendly staff! Loved the Philly cheese steak! Definitely recommend giving this place a try!

… more

Jake Oliger
Friendly staff, cozy bar, reasonably priced drinks, good food. Dan the bartender was very friendly, as were the whole staff. Stopped in out of necessity for a drink and a quick dinner, and they did not disappoint! I’ll be back if I’m back in Worthington with an hour or so to kill again.

… more

Evan W
It’ll be awhile before I come back. I’ve been a longtime fan of this place, but today the food was subpar. Mozzarella sticks were lukewarm and cheese was unmelted inside, the shrimp were some of the worst I’ve ever had (stale, tasteless) and my wife’s burger was mediocre at best. The dirty martini was bad/harsh (assuming it was well vodka) and it would’ve been nice to ask us which brand we preferred. Server was nice but also made the martini wrong and forgot the cheese to her burger.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions