Based on 181 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
2005 Bridgeport Ave, Milford, CT 06460
Phone: (203) 283-5433
Website: http://www.papaspizzaonline.com/
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dave & Teresa – Patrick Family Chem-Dry
Can’t say enough good things about Papas pizza 2! Love this locally owned restaurant and they just go above and beyond! We just had the breakfast pizza and it was AMAZING! We called very last minute and actually after they had closed and they still offered to make the pizza for us! Scott and Lenny were the nicest of guys and made you feel like family! Heads up this amazing breakfast pie is only available on Sundays!
… more
Tasha Mayberry
I wanted to just email the feedback to the company but your website has no email or form to contact you. The first time we went here the pizza was great. My husband ordered from here. So I decided to order my pizza here next time. I always get light cheese with fresh mushrooms and I specify 50% or more less cheese than normal. So half the cheese they usually put on. Unfortunately there was a ton of cheese on the pizza. I ended up ripping the cheese off and the mushrooms come off with it. So it’s just sauce and crust. If you’re ordering light cheese specify maybe a sprinkle of cheese. Not sure how else to explain light cheese. By the way, cheese bothers me but in small amounts it’s fine.
… more
Rebecca Hansen
Milford, are you kidding me. Do you mean to tell me this GEM of a pizza place exists when I’ve been going all the way to New Haven all these years. I picked up 7 pizzas today for a birthday party and despite the large order each pie was made perfectly. We got 3 cheese, 2 Roni, a di Rob and a di Madalena. People were raving. Great wood fired crust. The di Madalena was so good it was gone within 5 minutes. The kids loved the cheese and pepperoni, everyone was happy. And the people running this place are so nice – will be back.
… more
Benny Blanc
Pizza is . Definitely competes w New Haven. Family recipe is evident & their sauce is a 10 . Super cool staff. If you haven’t tried you’re missing out.
… more
Chris
Ordered a hour before and when I arrived, I was told I need to wait another 30 mins. I will never order from here again. Not even close to the Best pizza in milford…
… more
Carmen Sanchez
By far my favorite pizza spot in the area. You can keep all that hype New Haven over priced pizza. Sticking with my boys! Shoutout Scott!
… more
Jesse Vecchione
Good pizza at the price point. I’m not from Milford but it seems like Trenton style pizza mixed with New Haven (local) style. Enjoyed watching the family operation, reminded me of my childhood growing up in an Italian restaurant.
… more
Michael Taylor
Solid pie and great people who treat you right. They don’t over promise when you call and are honest when your pizza will be ready. There are many good choices in the area for pizza, but this place has consistently made great pizza. Worth avtrybif you haven’t already done so.
… more
Boris Domantovsky
This pizza is incredibly good, and I would genuinely eat this over almost any other pizza. I would eat this over Pepe’s and Modern and all the usuals. I’m sad it’s 30 minutes away for me normally but when I’m in the area and want great pizza I know where to go. Staff are great too which is a nice plus!
… more
Nancee Taylor
Our neighbors had us over for pizza last week from Papa‘s Pizza ll and we enjoyed it so much. Today we ordered our own and found it outstanding. We had a bacon, mushroom, and onion and thoroughly savored it. It is now our go to place for pizza for sure! Good job guys!
… more
… View more