Based on 344 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5 Lincolnway, Valparaiso, IN 46383
Phone: (219) 477-4992
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ryan Caird
I’ve always loved Peddlers. This however, I don’t even know what excuse there is for this. For the price of the pizza and for it to get delivered to me like this. I’m not happy. Pure laziness.
… more
Ana Scheidecker
Love this place! Service is wonderful, food selection is amazing, cocktails are on point. If you leave hungry, it’s 100% your own fault, haha.
… more
Nate Moore
The food was very good. Having grown up in chicago it’s hard to find good pizza that reminds me of the big city. But the crispy crust and fresh toppings (and variety) made it a very great eating experience
… more
Cathie Chapman
Wonderful! Delicious pizza. Crispy crust. Very tasty Italian sausage. Service was fast & friendly. Good selection of draft beer. Cozy atmosphere. Live music is way too loud. You can’t hear each other or even the lyrics. Our waitress got our order wrong because she couldn’t hear us
… more
Lemon Pandemic
I have a friend who just moved into a boarding house, and there’s a guy there named Steven. He’s a cook at Peddler’s. This guy hasn’t taken a shower literally in over a year, according to the other people there. When you walk down the hallway by his room, you can smell the stench the whole way. He urinates in bottles and keeps them in his room. The house managers have had to go in and remove garbage. He’s lived there two years, and is finally being kicked out for being a scumbag. No one there will eat at Peddler’s Pizza because this guy works there, and neither will I now that I know this.
… more
Daniel Zlatic
The pizzas are regularly under-baked. This last time I went, I asked for the pizza to be “well-done”; they brought it out to me looking like they hadn’t even put it in the oven. I sent it back to put back in the oven. When they brought back the second time, it looked barely warmed over. The only reason they are escaping this review with 3 stars is because the drinks are good, the barstaff pleasant, and the atmosphere is nice. But for a place that bills itself primarily for its pizza, it’s got a LONG way to go
… more
Robin Demaree
I love the atmosphere of this downtown pizza/salad/ craft cocktail Pub. Servers are friendly, cocktails are delicious and the pizza of the month is always a hit. The cracker crust is my new favorite pizza- why did it take me so long to try it?
… more
Vanessa Ellis
Shoutout to our server Catherine she was amazing & attentive! Shame on the cook! We were out celebrating our daughter’s birthday, party of five including our 20 month old grandson so timeliness is important. The cook forgot our birthday girl’s meal! It was delivered after most of us had finished. I’m not sure how the order was missed or why it wasn’t shot to the TOP of the list pushing remaining orders aside. Yes, we were provided a free dessert to compensate but that was no compensation for missing an order let alone on a birthday. Super disappointing!
… more
Superman99
I like this place and the service was very good but as much as I liked the food it was not anything to boast about. The pizza was similar to as if you were eating at MOD or Blaze. Plus be careful they charge for every ingredient so a $16 pizza when to almost $30 real quick.
… more
CINDY WHITESIDE
Waited over an hour for 2 sandwiches. Was told 2 different stories of why it was taking so long but the truth was forgot to put order in. Received food and it was cold and not even correct. We have given you several chances and it just keeps getting worse. Manager acted like taking them off our bill that she was doing us a favor. Last time pizza took over an hour. Time before that told 45 minute wait and it was literally 5 minutes. Get it together Peddlers. We are done giving you business. Management is not good and neither is service. Large turnover there with staff.
… more
… View more