Unpretentious eatery serving New York-style pizza, plus subs & hot wings, with delivery service. Based on 237 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1524 E Sumner St, Hartford, WI 53027
Phone: (262) 670-8532
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ellie Weller
We order from Sal’s all the time, we haven’t lately although since the last time we ordered. It was on a Sunday a couple weeks back and we placed our order online like usual. When I went to check my phone wondering where the food was I noticed 2 missed calls and it started ringing again. I answered and it was a woman who works at Sal’s asking if we would like to tip the driver? Which I thought was pretty rude and unprofessional to call and ask if we would leave a tip, which we always do, we always leave a chair out with money under a coaster. She called again while parked in front of my house after dropping the food off, from the same number that called 3 times before, so obviously it was the driver just begging for a tip. I was just appalled by the experience, as we are regulars who always tip. We hope this problem can be fixed so it doesn’t happen again, because now we’re very timid to order since I don’t want to get called and nagged to do something I’m already doing.
… more
Holly Jeffords
Crazy good New York-style pizza with friendly service. I’ve never received a single incorrect order here. Add feta cheese as one of your toppings and thank me later. Yum!
… more
The Renaissance lawn Guy
Best NYC pizza around.. we are originally from NY and this is our favorite pizza in Wisconsin so far
… more
Dave Lein
This small pizza restaurant has some of the best NY style pizza you will ever find. Been coming here for a decade and now live almost an hour away and will still come back a couple times a year for their pizza. Delicious!
… more
Kelly LaJoice
I had an awesome antipasto salad and Brooklyn Supreme Pizza. Both were excellent. Never been disappointed!!
… more
Matthew Kerhin
Best pizza in Hartford! Great Napolitano style crust and a sauce that isn’t sweet tomato paste garbage. Will be back!
… more
Jeff B
Simply the best pizza in the Hartford area! Delivery is always fast and everything is hot when it gets here!
… more
Rocco Slate
Awesome Pizza, How You Doing, we love Sal’s, we travel from southwest Milwaukee County just to enjoy there huge New York Style Pizza, great slice deals, excellent prices, it’s worth our time, we love this place, would highly recommend to Family and friends, see you soon, Rocco
… more
Jordan Dubey
Best pizza in southeast Wisconsin. Amazing pasta dinners, wings, and subs, too. The deepfried cheesecake is in its own realm of next level comfort food.
… more
joe m
Decent pizza, garlic knots are delicious. Crust could be a bit crunchier, oven a little hotter (I will probably request that next time). Great selection of pizza by the slice. All you can drink fountain soda. Reasonable prices.
… more
… View more