I Love New York Pizza Menu – Chapel Hill, NC

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Chapel Hill, NC

Based on 142 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

I Love New York Pizza 27516

Address:
106 W Franklin St #2516, Chapel Hill, NC 27516

Phone: (919) 968-4224

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 12 PM–12 AM
Thursday 12 PM–1 AM
Friday 12 PM–1 AM
Saturday 12 PM–1 AM
Sunday Closed
Monday Closed
Tuesday 12 PM–12 AM

Menu

Specialty Pizzas
New Yorker Cheese $14.95
Stuffed Meat Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham, and meatball. please note that no modifications can be accommodated.
$23.00
Meat Lovers Pizza $22.00
Primavera Pizza $22.00
Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms Pizza $22.00
Italian Chicken Pizza $22.00
Roma Spinach Pizza $21.00
Rio Rancho Pizza $21.00
Hawaiian Pizza $21.00
Lasagna Pizza $21.00
BBQ Chicken Pizza $21.00
Chicken Club Pizza $23.00
N.Y. Pizza $20.00
Chicken Buffalo Pizza $22.00
Pizza Slices
Plain Cheese $4.25
Sicilian $5.15
Cheese & Pepperoni $4.99
Salads
NY Salad $9.99
Caesar Salad
Green salad with caesar dressing and cheese.
$9.99
Chicken Salad $9.99
Greek Salad
Tomatoes cucumber onion and olives.
$9.99
Garden Salad
Green salad with mixed vegetables.
$9.99
Calzones
Cheese $10.99
Pepperoni $10.99
Broccoli
Broccoli and x-cheese.
$10.99
Ham $10.99
Meatball $10.99
Pizza Rolls
Ham, Spinach & Mushroom $10.99
Broccoli, Mushroom & Ham $10.99
Tomato, Feta & Spinach $10.99
Sausage, Pepperoni & Ham $10.99
Red Onion, Green Pepper & Sausage $10.99
Chicken, Mushroom & Green Pepper $10.99
Meatball, Banana Pepper & Pepperoni $10.99
N.Y. Strombolis
N.Y. Sausage
Italian sausage, GP, pepperoni.
$10.99
Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms $10.99
Italian Meatball
X-cheese and sauce.
$10.99
Great Western
Ground beef, green peppers, bbq sauce.
$10.99
Broccoli
Broccoli and x-cheese.
$10.99
Original NY. Ham
Green pepper and pepperoni.
$10.99
Specialty Slices
Roma Spinach $5.15
Rio Rancho $5.15
Italian Chicken $5.15
Bbq Chicken $5.15
Lasagna $5.15
Hawaiian $5.15
Meat Lovers $5.15
Primavera $5.15
Stuffed Meat $5.15
Chicken Club $5.15

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jarrad Sims
The guy is a con artist. Charged 28$ for 4 pieces of pizza when a whole one only cost about 20$. Also he has a skimmer on his card reader because my card got hacked after going there. Horrible person running the place -5 stars

… more

Brad Russell
Iconic Chapel Hill restaurant, family owned, been eating here for 20 years, open late and serves classic thin NYC style MONSTER sized slices. Can get super crowded by drunken undergrads late night but you can still get in and out with a great slice or two, or a whole pie. Food costs are brutal right now for small local places so $5 a slice is seemingly high but look at what you get, it’s worth it. Eat local.

… more

Anna M Hatcher
It was okay place, definitely needs cleaning and hygiene touch, restrooms and floor has to be cleaned. No visitors Friday 5 pm. The cooker does all work here and cooking, and POS cashier and I guess cleaning is on him. He is working hard, but I would like two different pairs of hand to touch my food and pin pad. Owner what are you thinking about? Why one guys is in the place which has a capacity for 40 people?

… more

Dustin Stumbo
I was charged 29$ for 4 slices of pizza and a cup of water. I was then asked if I had any cash and when I said no he seemed quite frustrated. I didn’t realize I had been overcharged until I got home. Is the menus here a cash price only kind of thing? Is the price different when you pay with a card? 7.25$ for 4 slices of cheese is far to expensive when you can get a whole pizza elsewhere for half the price of what I got charged for 4 slices.

… more

Jimmy Fay
They’ve been a reliable late night option for years. Solid pizza with great toppings

… more

Koun Lim
I wouldn’t recommend eating here. Pizza is very dry. I ordered cheese and lasagna pizza slides and those are what I got. Too dry to eat crust. And…whatever I got for lasagna is nowhere near completion. The place is old and dirty. There are way better restaurants near for this quality of food at cheaper prices.

… more

Braden Hunter
This place is a scam. Prices are outrageous for some old pizza being reheated. You must have a $7 minimum which means you can’t get just one slice. They take advantage of drunk college students who come in for a late food run. No chance I go back.

… more

Amar Qasem
I buy pizza from you and I saw it burnt. It is forbidden for you to sell pizza like this. We buy with our money and not for free. These things we will not be silent about. We will file a case for this shop. you charged me $40 for one XL why It’s burnt pizza and we threw it in the trash Everyone please see this picture

… more

Del Capslock
The owner charges you a different price everytime based on who you are/ are with. Guy is an a$$hole and takes advantage of drunk college students selling 6 dollar slices of old pizza. IP3 is 3x better if you want a good slice. Only positive is they are open late. Do better slimey geezer

… more

Jasmine Gailliard
i’ve gotten food here at least twice and BOTH times i got physically ill (once even threw up). Definitely would not recommend the stromboli or calzone because i don’t believe it’s fresh and that’s how i got sick from it ://

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions