Pizzeria Scotty Menu – West Allis, WI

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : West Allis, WI

Long-running standby for traditional thin-crust & deep-dish pies, plus casual Italian favorites. Based on 842 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Pizzeria Scotty 53227

Address:
9022 W Oklahoma Ave, West Allis, WI 53227

Phone: (414) 543-1300

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–10 PM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Pizza
10 Inch Build Your Own $11.35
10 Inch Gluten Free $13.35
12 Inch Build Your Own $13.65
14 Inch Build Your Own $16.65
16 Inch Build Your Own $19.25
10 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles		 $17.60
12 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles		 $21.60
14 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles		 $23.60
16 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles		 $26.80
10 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!		 $17.60
12 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!		 $21.60
14 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!		 $23.60
16 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!		 $26.80
10 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom		 $17.60
12 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom		 $21.60
14 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom		 $23.60
16 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom		 $26.80
10 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $17.60
12 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $21.60
14 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $23.60
16 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $26.80
10 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $17.60
12 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $21.60
14 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $23.60
16 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom		 $26.80
10 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese		 $17.60
12 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese		 $21.60
14 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese		 $23.60
16 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese		 $26.80
10 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!		 $17.60
12 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!		 $21.60
14 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!		 $23.60
16 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!		 $26.80
10 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!		 $20.40
12 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!		 $24.40
14 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!		 $27.50
16 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!		 $31.60
Appetizers
Breaded Mushroom Regular $4.65
Breaded Mushroom Half Tray $15.85
Breaded Mushroom Full Tray $30.30
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Regular $4.50
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Half Tray $12.00
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Full Tray $22.00
French Fries Regular $2.90
French Fries Half Tray $9.60
French Fries Full Tray $17.80
Garlic Bread $3.10
Garlic Bread Half Tray $11.60
Garlic Bread Full Tray $20.30
Mozzarella Sticks Regular $7.50
Mozzarella Sticks Half Tray $28.60
Mozzarella Sticks Full Tray $55.30
Scotty’s Sticks
10 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.		 $11.00
12 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.		 $13.50
14 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.		 $16.00
16 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.		 $18.50
Chicken
Boneless Wings Regular $8.75
Boneless Wings Pound $16.75
Boneless Wings Half Tray $32.50
Boneless Wings Full Tray $63.00
Regular Wings Regular $8.75
Regular 12 Wings $16.75
Regular Wings Half Tray $32.50
Regular Wings Full Tray $63.00
Sandwiches
The “Big Cheese”
one-third pound of delicious, thin sliced italian beef served on french bread smothered with melted mozzarella		 $8.05
Italian Beef $6.85
Meatball Sandwich $6.40
Pizza Bread $6.35
Pastas
Baked Lasagna Regular
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $12.00
Baked Lasagna Half Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $45.00
Baked Lasagna Full Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $88.00
Mostaccioli Regular
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $7.35
Mostaccioli Half Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $26.50
Mostaccioli Full Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $47.00
Cheese Ravioli Regular
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $8.85
Cheese Ravioli Half Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $31.50
Cheese Ravioli Full Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.		 $57.00
Sides
Anchovies $2.00
Beef Juice $1.00
Coleslaw $1.30
French Bread $1.30
Hot Giardiniera $1.00
Hot Peppers $1.00
Marinara Sauce $1.00
Meatballs (3) $3.70
Pepperoncini $1.00
Pizza Sauce $1.00
Side BBQ $1.00
Side Blue Cheese Dressing $1.00
Side Buffalo $1.00
Side Ranch $1.00
Sweet Peppers $1.00
Slices
Pepperoni Slice $3.50
Sausage Slice $3.50
Cheese Slice $3.50
Beverages
Can Pepsi $1.25
Can Diet Pepsi $1.25
Can Mountain Dew $1.25
Bottle Water $1.25
2-Liter Pepsi $3.50
2-Liter Diet Pepsi $3.50
2-Liter Mountain Dew $3.50
6-Pack Pepsi $7.15
6-Pack Diet Pepsi $7.15
6-Pack Mt. Dew $7.15
6-Pack Water $7.15

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

William Low
I’ve always heard how good the pizza was here but never had a chance to have it we decided they have it for our rehearsal dinner the night before our wedding at our church and we were just amazed at how good it was and the delivery person was fantastic bringing it down stairs for us. He said that the pizza is excellent and that’s not just because he works there and he was right! We’ll be back for sure you have two new customers that live way down in Hales Corners

… more

Justin Provance
Finally tried this locally owned pizza place a friend recommend and am glad I did. Everything looked good and the most delicious smells filled the place. We ultimately couldn’t decide so ended up getting a double dough and a stuffed pizza. The food was amazing and so were the leftovers! My opinion is this place beats the big chains in taste and price!

… more

Owen
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Deep dish is amazing, and their hours are even better. Being open till 11 pm is incredible on my schedule at least.

… more

Charles Mahoney
Tremendous pizza and attentive service. So glad I tried this pizzeria. Prices and wait times may be higher than average, but the quality of the pizza you get is well worth it. Plan accordingly.

… more

Tiffany Moore
Was my first time eating here a few days ago. Absolutely LOVED it. I ordered a veggie pizza it was delicious fresh & hot. The service was awesome. I will be back sooner than they think 🙂

… more

John Tice
We have ordered pizzas for take out a couple of times now and Pizzeria Scotty has jumped to the top of our families favorite pizzeria. The food is wonderful and the price is right in line with others. We won’t order from anyone else!!!

… more

Jennifer Mansavage
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Delivery can be slow sometimes so you have to plan ahead. When I’ve picked up, the guys are always super friendly.

… more

Ian Smith
Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Deep dish is amazing, and their hours are even better. Being open till 11 pm is incredible on my schedule at least.

… more

Chris Hill
I showed up to pick up my pizza about 15 minutes early. I paid and was told it would be about 20 minutes. No problem. About 40 minutes later I had to ask if my pizza was ready. It was in the warmer for how long I have no idea. It wasn’t the usual awesome pizza it was warm at best. It wasn’t worth the money I spent that’s for sure. There was about 15 other people in the same situation waiting. They need a better system.

… more

Jamie Wojczak
Hello!!

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Toppers Pizza Menu – West Allis, WI
  2. Flour Girl & Flame Menu – West Allis, WI
  3. KFC Menu – West Allis, WI
  4. Steakhouse100 Menu – West Allis, WI

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch