Corey Creek Inn Menu – Blue Point, NY

Type : Bar & grill

Location : Blue Point, NY

Charming outlet offering American fare like burgers & steaks in a cozy house with wood wainscoting. Based on 55 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$

Corey Creek Inn 11715

Address:
154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715

Phone:

Website:

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Kevin Armato
Enjoyed a sirloin steak which was slightly over cooked for medium but it was still good. The cut of meat was ok but a little tough. The mushrooms on top were very flavorful. Had the calamari for an app and it was perfect. The chili sauce was great. Although the meal was good i would not return. There are lots of places on long island to eat. Try it out you might like it, you might even love it! The owner and his wife seem very friendly and personable.

… more

Donna Zabo
Absolutely amazing! Can’t wait to go again!

… more

Geraldina Salcedo
The Pomtini is delicious!!!

… more

Jan Kotowski-Chang
One of the best meals I have had in a long time. The crabcake is moist and full of crab. The seafood stew was the best I have ever had. Service is attentive and accommodating. We found this place on our way home. Will absolutely drive 30 minutes east to visit again.

… more

Dano
This restaurant is top notch. From the first time we discovered this place, we had an amazingly satisfying night only to be topped by the next visit and the next one after that! The food is amazing, the staff is awesome and the prices are excellent. You really must check it out, I don’t ever write reviews but I honestly feel this place deserves to be mentioned.

… more

David Haliwell
Where do I start on this experience? So most of the dishes my friends and i ordered was pre frozen, overcooked and lacked flavor. The only good thing about this place is the staff. I heard that the chef went to school in Italy and wow, what a huge repulsive disappointment in tasting what Italy had to offer, i would rather spend my time eating prison food then to eat here again. 75.00? This was absolutely the biggest rip off in the industry by far. They are fortunate enough to get 1 star

… more

Margaret Ashby
This place sucks!! My previous employer used this place for our Company Christmas party 2 years in a row. And, because I don’t eat meat (I only went to show support for the company) – I had to wait until EVERYONE else had gotten their food and had already started to eat before they would make me a simple plate of pasta. And, I have to say, it sooooo wasn’t worth the wait. At least now that the company is closed I will never have to step foot in there again.

… more

paul mann
First waitress never told me the specials, bread was cold, food was good but takes forever and then some, still wondering how a piece of aluminum foil wound up in it. Still waiting for the owner to lmk on that one. Offered me a piece of apple pie for all the troubles waited like 20 minutes before I told waitress to bring me the check & wrap up the not seen slice of pie. Don’t know how this place got 4 stars

… more

Theresa O’Rourke
Went tonight (New Years eve) didn’t want the price fix (too much food) they accommodated us and let us order off the menu. Absolutely delightful. Husband had the osso bucco, I had the seafood Fra Diavolo. Wonderful evening. Wonderful food. Very cozy too! We plan on coming again.

… more

dean anderson
Place looked nice and clean , I would look for a New chef, the Hanger steak was tough with no favor , my wife got osso Buco ,it was tough also my stuffed potato was old tasting and my wife’s potatoes seemed like instant potatoes, this was one of my worst dinners since I got to Long Island. The server’s were no better. It sure wasn’t worth 75.00 .

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions