Family-owned pizza joint with a modest dine-in area plus Italian entrees, salads & subs. Based on 448 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1063 Fairmount Ave, Elizabeth, NJ 07201
Phone: (908) 289-2277
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jennifer M. Costa
Awesome famous favorite local pizzeria! The food is fantastic… Tony Pizza is the owner, an attraction and the entertainment just being himself! This place brings the real flare of Italian-American authentic simplicity!!! BYOB… there is a liquor store w/in walking distance.
… more
The Renaissarian
Better Than Average Parlor Pizza… Can Taste the Garlic and Seasoning…
… more
dan73nyc Alvarado
I have lives in NYC my entire life-North of Brooklyn aka, Williamsburg! Diggs Ave PizZa held the crown until it sold to Two Boots Pizza!
… more
Chuck Mound
Was pleasantly surprised upon my visit for a quick grab n go slice. I lucked out with a fresh pie that just came out of the oven. Tommy’s goes with a thin Pizza that has some flop, but delivers on the sauce and cheese. A good tasting slice that was worth the stop. The man behind the counter was very nice and provided excellent customer service. 4 slices and a drink was $11.35. Will add them to the Pizza Hunters App.
… more
Bill Savage
Been coming to Tommy’s since I was a kid, used to be one of the best pies in Elizabeth. Unfortunately the last 2 times I’ve gotten pizza from them it’s been very bland and dry. Something has changed in their recipe and how they cook the pizza.
… more
Chris Vega
Unfortunately until tonight I was a good customer at this so called family establishment. Normally things are on the up and up when I order but tonight I had my wife order and they saw it as a good opportunity to screw us over. The menu clearly states the calamari is 12 dollars and large pie is 16 plus 2 dollar delivery fee and a soda. Do the math.. 28 plus a soda let’s say is 5 on the high end…33 dollars is about the total. We were charged 42 dollars. (Not including the 8 dollar tip i gave) Initially unaware I called and asked why the major price difference according to the menu to which I was told everything is only 3 dollars more per item as per the manager And that “it was not a big deal”..basically telling me to just shut up and pay it. when I proceeded to explain that it was not right to do that to customers i was then let known that it wasn’t the service reps problem….it goes without saying…. never again..
… more
Nel tana (Philly)
I will NEVER order from here. Do not order a cheesesteak, I did with fried onions what I got was a onion sandwich so gross. The bread was dry and it broke off. “Not fresh bread” I also ordered wings geez they were so dry you could see through the bone. The food was horrible way over priced NOT worth it. I did not eat it waste of money. Find another place.
… more
Christopher Torres
Very upset with my food. I ordered a calzone (which usually has ricotta and mozzarella then any added toppings. I asked for bacon and broccoli. The bacon was ALL bacon fat. As seen in pictures
… more
JC JC
I love this place best pizza ever. I live in south jersey. When my job sends me up north I make sure I stop in here for sure. Pizza so good my favorite barbecue ranch
… more
Matthew
stopped in here as a MUST after a long morning of flying and JEEEEEEEZ THIS PLACE BLEW ME AWAY.
… more
… View more