Intimate, family-run kitchen doling out hearty Italian staples, including housemade pasta & risotto. Based on 500 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
426 S Main St, Old Forge, PA 18518
Phone: (570) 451-0433
Website: http://www.caferinaldi.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 5–9 PM |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | 5–9 PM |
| Saturday | 5–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michele Auster
Went for a birthday dinner. Not an extensive menu but good choices with pasta, chicken and veal. Portions are huge. Next time may opt for a side order of pasta with meatballs. Nice atmosphere and great attentive service. Don’t forget to make reservations because you won’t get a seat.
… more
Chris Langley
Can’t say enough about this place. First time my wife and I were there. Got an app that they said was for 2 but I think they meant for 2 weeks. The chicken rinaldi was fantastic!!
… more
Tim Lavelle
You Need To Know? Arrived at 530 on a Friday night with reservations. Service was rapid & extremely pleasant. Ordered the chicken & cheese risotto balls, a tray of Old Forge style pizza half meatballs, & manicotti. The risotto balls were absolutely delicious. Wish they would have given more. The manicotti had an amazing red sauce & they gave you 4 of them & was very filling. There pizza was airy & light with a crispy crunchy crust! Very tasty & no need to order Xtra cheese as it is loaded with it. This place is a must eat! Now You Know! -TBH
… more
Margarita Kaminski
Amazing food. Great service. Love this place and will definitely go back!
… more
Donald Sparacino
Absolutely love it here, great, friendly service, family atmosphere, excellent food & big portions, highly recommend & get there soon.
… more
Rob Oatman
The pizza was absolutely beautiful, boasting a light, crispy crust. Somehow, though, the flavor seemed a bit mild. The service was above average. No Coke or Pepsi, so I opted for a 7UP with my meal. I highly recommend the fries, as they tasted and looked homemade. A really good-looking restaurant.
… more
Jim Too
Risotto is still the best I’ve had anywhere. We had dinner here on a Wednesday evening, not at all busy. Service was very good. A few slight negatives: no Bianco though it was on the wine list, salads with dinner were just a tiny bit of ice berg lettuce, a couple cuke slices and a couple of cherry tomatoes. Also add a fee for using a credit card.
… more
karen bingham
One of my family’s favorite places to eat!!!! Food is always amazing!!! Tracy our server is the best!!! We Love you all!!!
… more
joe landmark
Agree with others. Food does not appear to be house made. Sauce tastes and looked like tomato paste or ketchup. This was confirmed when car parked near trash bins showed Heinz tomato sauce cans. I had no idea Heinz even made sauce. My Chicken parm was undercooked. Salad was all iceberg, most white leaves with tasteless “house” dresssing and two paper thin slices of cucumber and three cherry tomatoes. It is summer, one would think the salad would be chock full of fresh salad items. Not here. The risotto everyone raves about was frozen broccoli, microwaved chicken breast and tasteless heavy cream with Kraft parm. If you grew up with frozen vegetables, boxed pasta and canned Heinz sauce, then this place will taste like “homemade”. The five star reviews must be friends and family, not discernable Customers. This place appears to be living off past reputation and are now just relying on Sysco cafeteria food service rather than spending hours of prep work before opening. Very sad.
… more
Ralph Mifka
The food is always consistently good They are our top 10 to go to restaurants.
… more
… View more