Based on 363 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
1440 Oneida St, Appleton, WI 54915
Phone: (920) 830-8336
Website: https://www.wiseguysappleton.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4:30–8 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4:30–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4:30–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Maxzeus
Walking in we were greeted immediately and she set us down at a table. Our server caner shorty after to get our drinks. We ordered cheese bread and motz sticks along with two sausage, Pepperoni, onion pizzas. Food took a little longer than than expected for the amount of people but could have had alot of takeouts. When the apps came the cheese we were a little disappointed as it was just a piece of toast with cheese on it and motz sticks two were hollow and had no cheese in them.. When the pizzas came they looked great! Pizza had nice ratio of topping to sauce. Really no complaints on the pizza. The apps I prob will not get for the price of them. Over all good pizza, good atmosphere, if in the area would come back.
… more
Carl
I was looking for some good pizza. I didn’t want the cookie cutter chain style pizza. This place is definitely legit. I went with the hand tossed and it did not disappoint. Perfect balance of chewy/crunchy crust. I really enjoyed the cheesy goodness.
… more
Cassandra Kent
Good stuffed Chicago style pizza. It does take a while to make it, so if you’re really hungry plan on ordering an appetizer. We had garlic bread this time, but we have also enjoyed the mozzarella sticks and split a salad. We went at 5:30 on a Friday and were able to be seated right away. The dining area has always been dark and cozy, but with March Madness going on they were playing basketball on most of the tvs. Like halfway through our meal they turned up the volume so much so that the conversation at our table turned to shouting to be able to hear each other. They have a good drink menu here, and when the weather is nice they have a patio that they allow you to bring your dog to while you eat . Also on Fridays they have fish fry options on the menu as well.
… more
Ryan Williamson
We read a few of the negative reviews and we experienced the exact opposite. The food, service, drinks, and especially the environment were amazing!
… more
Page Sayeski
We really wanted to love this place as it’s a very cute restaurant and the staff is super friendly. However, the food is just not worth the price tag. The $8 cheesy garlic bread is two pieces of toast with mozzarella cheese slices melted on top and the deep dish pizza came out luke-warm without that special flavor that one would expect from a deep dish. One of the martinis I had was not drinkable and tasted like cleaning solution but the waitress did get me a different one which was a bit better. Again, the staff is VERY friendly and accommodating, nothing but good things to say there. Overall, we left spending $70 on a meal that we didn’t feel satisfied with. There are many great pizza places in the Valley and unfortunately this is not one of them in my opinion. It could be an acceptable place for lunch or dinner if the prices came down exponentially.
… more
roman c
Our 1st time Here and the food was awesome A pizza was Delicious My four-year-old daughter got spaghetti And finished before everyone And she said it was super good Full bar Good fish tacos on Friday and all sorts of sandwiches restaurants Atmosphere and decorations are supremely cool The restaurant is dim And I liked it
… more
Charlotte Wynen
Amazing place, cozy atmosphere, very nice staff. Ordered the homemade alfredo and added chicken, mushrooms, spinach, and artichoke. Super tasty and filling. Definitely trying the pizza next time!
… more
Michael Dobratz
Even though they seemed short handed, the guys were always there with a soda or water refill. Chicago pizza was fabulous, My wife’s thin crust looked and smelled great. Definitely go again
… more
Damien Green
I grabbed a Chicago stuffed deep dish just because I had a taste for it. After researching the Appleton area, the best two were Wiseguys and a place I will not mention. I chose Wiseguys because, let’s be honest, it’s a pretty cool name. The pizza was very fresh as far as the ingredients. I had the spicy sausage and it was made pretty good. I was super pleased overall and definitely will be back.
… more
Larry Snap
Your pizza is the best in north east Wisconsin hands down. The 50 min wait for the deep dish worth the wait. All your food and drinks are amazing.
… more
… View more