Based on 126 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1123 N 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: (920) 452-2702
Website: http://www.peabodyspizza.com/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Enjoli Jeffries
The food is decent, it’s the creepy lady that gives me “Karen vibes! Every time I order from there, it’s a issue or something racially strange that happens. I won’t go into details but I hope you see this message and analyze and approve yourself with customer service towards your black customers. It’s 2023! You can’t judge us all by the same book!
… more
Lynn Suring
I love their food. Except I tried something new this time, it was the BLT with their special sauce (I was so sick, my dog was given a couple of bites, she was sick all night). I everything they make, never had an issue before. I will still order. I think maybe the sauce was bad.
… more
Christopher O’Brien
First, I’m from New England where real pizza is made. So, cheese heads, pay attention!
… more
Margaret Spencer
I would actually give them a 3.5/3.75 if Google would let me. We tried it for the first time and it was just average. The good: They are really good at loading their toppings on the pizza so you get some of everything in each bite. The price is very reasonable considering how much you get. Unfortunately, the bad outweighs the good. We ordered the garlic cheese dippers, which tasted nothing like garlic, but rather all I could taste was rosemary. It does come with a good amount of cheese, but the garlic is a very subtle after taste and rosemary slaps you in the face. They were great and let us do a 1/2 and 1/2 pizza. On one side we did the Meat Head and the other half Ultimate Hawaiian. Unfortunately, with both of them having bacon bits instead of real bacon on them the bacon bits get extremely dry when they get cooked in the oven. It makes for a very unpleasant chewing experience. If they were to put the bacon bits on afterwards or towards the end of cooking then they wouldn’t dry out so much and it would be much better. On the ultimate Hawaiian the onions were too powerful. With them using so much toppings on you just tasted it in every bite. Next time I will ask them to maybe use them more sparingly throughout the pizza. Lastly, not that it’s a bad thing, but they definitely don’t use a lot of sauce on their pizza so if you’re one that likes a good amount of sauce you may need to ask for extra.
… more
Travis Haage
Pretty disappointed. The veggie pizza was bland and a bit dry. A parmesan shaker at the counter would go a long way. I ordered the 10 inch pizza over the 7-in because I wanted something leftover. Turns out that I got a barely 8.5 inch pizza and was still a bit hungry. Nothing special here at this hole-in-the-wall and I wish I had gone to Toppers just a few block away instead.
… more
C Brock
Best pizza in Sheboygan. Always delivered hot. Great deals throughout the week. Unlike other pizza’s there is almost no grease on the bottom of the box. Best tasting pizza of all.
… more
Nancy Schmidtman
First timers. Pizza was delicious. Fast and friendly. We will be back.
… more
Matthew Brulla
Don’t let the storefront fool you. What they lack in seating (there is none…it’s takeout only) and pretty colors they make up in the most amazing Taco Pizza in town. Been going for years and it’s always a hit in our household.
… more
Greg Lensink
Ordered delivery on website, somehow pizza had no sauce.
… more
Karen Brady
Ordered several pizzas for a family get together. Upon opening the first pizza box, a piece of black hair was found in the cheese/sauce. Pizza was not touched due to findings and left a negative impression. Contacted establishment the next day to inform them of findings. No apology extended. Will not patronize Peabody’s any more due to lack of apology. Situations happen, it’s how you respond or not respond to them that keeps loyal customers coming back.
… more
… View more