Based on 63 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
620 Butler Crossing Suite 2, Butler, PA 16001
Phone: (724) 256-8258
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Big Bake on the Move
Walked in at 8:45pm they were closing… I got 5star service without a dirty look and I still apologized for coming in last minute but I had just gotten into town and just got my hotel room. I asked for a recommendation and the chef hooked me up very quickly I was in and out of the restaurant in about 7 minutes… super fresh food and the place was spotless! If you don’t know which pizza place to choose and are looking for “that” spot! This is it trust me! I got the chicken bacon ranch with a chef salad and a chocolate chip cookie and a bottled tea. 5stars all the way!
… more
Jessi Barber
So fun & so good!
… more
Zach Landon
Service was quick and very pleasant. Answered every question I asked with detail and a smile. Now down to the main point. THE FOOD!!!!!….. Girlfriend got the Alfredo Chicken Pasta Bowl.. first reaction was OMG SO GOOD. Daughter got the Pierogie Pizza… she shared with her baby brother and the both scarfed it down like they would never be feed again. She couldn’t stop talking about how amazing it was. Myself I got a make your own pizza. CHICKEN BACON MOZZARELLA CHEDDAR PINEAPPLE WITH BUTTER&GARLIC SAUCE WITH A DRIZZLE OF HOT HONEY ON TOP. Hands down the most fantastic and tasteful. Pizza I have had in 20 years! I recommend Third Eye Pie to everyone and anyone! BEST PIZZA IN BUTLER! HANDS DOWN! It’s affordable and delicious and I say that with 100% Truth. I have eaten at over 100 Pizza shops through out the country. Third Eye Pie is my new #1!
… more
EMILY THOMM
We tried third eye pies for the first time tonight and it was delicious. Fast & Friendly service and atmosphere. Good prices.
… more
Megan Alissa
I knew what this restaurant was like going into it as my family member has eaten there multiple times. I enjoyed that you could build your pie or pick a prebuilt option. There were many options for vegetarian, vegan, and gluten free diets. There was also the option to not use tomato sauce, which was helpful for a family member. I thought the design and layout out of the restaurant was cute and unique. I thoroughly enjoy my pizza.
… more
Gina Evans
My first time there, Butler location. Had a build your own, the crust is excellent and they do not skimp on the toppings. The employees were super friendly and explained everything to me as I have visual impairment and couldn’t really see the menu. Would definitely recommend and will be back.
… more
Wendy Meals
First time ordering from here. I had it delivered. This pizza is the best that I have had in Butler! I love the option of fresh sliced mozzarella! The red sauce is amazing (be sure to order extra on the side for dipping)! Definitely my go to from now on! YUM!
… more
Lisa Murano
This was our first time here and we really enjoyed the pizzas! Next time we’re bringing the whole family so we can try a dessert pizza too! I had a chicken parmesan pizza and the husband had something with peppers on it and he was really pleased that it had some real spice to it!
… more
Tara Zynel
Was very excited about the concept of this pizza place, the design and aesthetic are very appealing. Expected to find something like Sublime playing inside considering all the hippie/psychedelic style decor, instead nothing but country ballads. The online menu doesn’t make clear the size of the pies that are available, glad I went in to order otherwise I would’ve been very disappointed in the size of the “half pie.” Setup inside looks more like an ice cream shop or a subway. Ordered the Nashville hot pie and the Mac and Cheese pie. The bacon on the Mac pie may have been kept above safe food storage temps (bacon on the makeline was piled far higher than the refrigerated walls of the container keeping it room temp for too long) and was clearly rancid upon eating, rendering the rest of the pie inedible. The menu also doesn’t make clear that the “crust” is a thin cracker style. Disappointed, will not return. Great concept idea, terrible execution.
… more
chris rusch
Excellent food at a great price with a cool experience
… more
… View more