The owner and employees of Boardwalk Pizza pride themselves on providing only the freshest ingredients in all of their dishes, including their pastas, hot and cold subs, and, of course, their famous pizza, which received a raving review by food critic Scott Joseph. In addition, Boardwalk Pizza offers fast, friendly, family-oriented service that draws a crowd of regular patrons as well as new and referred customers every day. So if you are looking for a place to bring the family for great food and a relaxing atmosphere, you’ve come to the right place.
Relaxed Italian counter serve for classic pizza, hoagies & pastas with gluten- & dairy-free options. Based on 572 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5419 Lake Howell Rd, Winter Park, FL 32792
Phone: (407) 671-6880
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eric Cantillo
I recently visited Boardwalk Pizza and I must say, I was extremely disappointed. The food was disgusting. The garlic knots were hard, stale, and didn’t taste fresh. The slices of pizza were overpriced and didn’t taste fresh either. It was a complete waste of money. However, my server Noah was the one bright spot in an otherwise terrible experience. He was great – very attentive and made sure my drink was always full. The only positive aspect aside from Noah’s service was that the restaurant appeared well-kept and clean. However, this didn’t make up for the subpar quality of the food. Overall, it was a highly disappointing experience and I would not recommend Boardwalk Pizza to anyone.
… more
Max McNeill
I have probably ordered take out pizza from here at least 20 times now. The pizza is always fresh, perfect amount of sauce and cheese. The garlic knots are great too. My coworker is from NY and even she has good things to say about their pizza. Highly recommend.
… more
Brian O’Donnell
Had a hankering for a good pizza. My first time here. Walked in and saw an elderly couple enjoying a spaghetti & meatball meal that looked delicious so I ordered 1 slice of pizza and the spaghetti meal with 1/2 meatballs & 1/2 sausage. The pizza was great and the spaghetti even better. Meatballs were like none I’ve ever tasted before and they were delicious. I’ll be back to try the Philly cheesesteak and the Stromboli. I told them I’m from Philly and they promised it would not disappoint. I look forward to being back . Oh, I got a piece of chocolate cake to go also
… more
David Ursin
Every time I go to Boardwalk pizza I always leave a happy customer. The pizza is very tasty and the service is great. I highly recommend you try this place out.
… more
Alysha Anderson
My husband ordered a pie from this place it was the worst we have ever tried in life. The bread was extremely thin and extra crispy. Getting home 5 minutes later and it cutting it sound like cutting toast. My kids were upset crying they said it was to dry no taste. It barely had sauce. The sauce mush have only been reserved for the top near the crust because pulling back the cheese there was no red no sauce. There was barely cheese oil. It was like cardboard and dry cheese. Never in my house does a pie of pizza sit and go in the trash. New york nothing. I lived in Brooklyn NY all my life moved hear 5 years ago, this pissa horrid. Horrid even for fl
… more
Nilo Nogueras
Real great pizza nice crust definitely New York style loaded with meat like ridiculous amounts of meat would definitely come here and recommend coming here to eat here a little bit far away from home but loved it.
… more
Kate Burns
Pizza is better than the pasta dishes. Servers are always attentive. Good slice specials. I enjoy the house balsamic dressing the most !
… more
Ares Olympius
Great pizza place in winter park. We’ve been coming here for a couple years. They make their own ingredients, to include their own ranch dressing, and it tastes great.
… more
Addey
Extremely disappointed and dissatisfied. I’ve been here before and loved it. With that being said this time I didn’t even eat. We walked in and told them we were going to sit outside. After waiting about 10mins and getting no service not even waters or menus we left. Mind you the were not busy at ALL. all of the tables were empty. Do better.
… more
Sean Murphy
I love this place, particularly the cheesesteaks, but pricing has gotten ridiculous. I know that prices have gone up everywhere, but they have gone up much more at Boardwalk than elsewhere. I’m a 20 year fan, but looking for other places
… more
… View more