Based on 393 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1349 Park Ave W, Mansfield, OH 44903
Phone: (419) 709-8755
Website: https://horseshoeburgerco.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–3 AM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tina Harshbarger
So good that we visited twice while visiting the area. The food was really, really good. The chicken was just ok, but the burgers were amazing. The show stealer was the Mansfield Philly. The sandwich was huge and stuffed full of meat and good flavor. It was hands down the best thing on the menu!
… more
Heather “Queenie”
We had the Texas Rattlesnake burger with fries & the Philly with okra.
… more
Kody Fowler
We tried to give this place one last shot after hearing that the owner had “listened to feedback.”
… more
Jessica Hopkins
Traveling on the highway and googled food near me and Horseshoe Burger Company came up. It sounded interesting so we decided to give it a try. We are so happy we did!
… more
Michael Adams
I was really hoping for better quality given all the prior rave reviews. First the good. Looks nice and they obviously spent some money on the interior. Our waitress was polite, helpful and efficent. The bad. We ordered burgers, fries and the Onion rings and pepsi. I had hoped that a place marketing its self as a burger joint would use fresh products, it became quickly obvious that everything is frozen. The fries obviously came from a bag and you can see from the picture I must have gotten the bottom of the bag because they were mostly small overly fried bits of potato. I don’t know why a burger joint that only offers three sides would not do fresh cut fries. The Onion rings were super mushy on the inside while the outside was cooked. I had the melt. They advertise angus beef and it might be but the patties looked like premade frozen patties. The other person with me had the pineapple burger. The bacon on the burger was fatty and undercooked. If your going to put bacon on a sandwich it should be crispy. The burgers were fine if not overly salty. The highlight of the food was the dipping sauce provided with the onion rings, some kind of bbq-esque sauce that I enjoyed. Over all two of us had a small meal and paid $48 with a tip. That’s pretty pricey given the quality of the products.
… more
Carla Miller
Found this place by pure accident. Def will NOT be my last visit. Flavor: on point. Serving size: Wow . Clean. Friendly staff. Ordered was a classic cheeseburger w their Mac n cheese. Mansfield Philly w jalapenos added and fries. Loaded tots as an appetizer. I got a side of the ghost pepper wing sauce for my fries. Literally the best ghost pepper sauce I have ever eaten and that is saying TONS. One place that should be visited for sure. I’m lucky it’s on 30 mins from me.
… more
Chris Ditmars
I was going to update this review a little bit because i dealt with a lot better staff yesterday than i had previously. And then i noticed that the owner claims my previous bad experience was due to him “cutting me off” sir that was not true and if that is what you would like to claim i only ask why would that have anything to do with you not giving me my food. You have went through so many staff members because you treat them worse than your customers. I’ve been here several times and today is the first time that I had to directly deal with the owner. He is terrible. He has no hospitality. They don’t really care about their customers. Someone comes in and they act like they want to help serve them and then 10 minutes they act like you don’t exist. I ordered food and five people that ordered their food after me received their food first. I’m not picky. I don’t expect things to be perfect. But the owner himself was rude and very disappointing
… more
Asaad Bakhashwain
No better place in the area to get burgers and fries. Period.
… more
Kody Fowler
With incredible burgers, buns toasted to perfection, generous fry portions (best tasting fries ever btw), very fast/friendly service, and actually reasonable prices .. you have ZERO reason to not eat here for dinner tonight!! 10/10 WILL DEFINITELY be eating here more often!
… more
Patty Burkhalter
First time ever been here, swiss cheese burger was lightly toasted on brioche bun. So good. Also the deep fried pickle. Reasonable price for the amount I got.
… more
… View more