Based on 124 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
3600 College Rd A, Wilmington, NC 28412
Phone: (910) 791-7080
Website: https://jaysincredible.com/
Reviews
Karen Larkin
Ordered this pizza for the first time and got the incredible.
… more
Drew Bell
This is my new go-to pizza place in Wilmington! The wait times on weekends or busy nights can be pretty long, but that’s to be expected for quality pizza. All the interactions I’ve had with the staff have been pleasant and friendly. I haven’t ordered anything from here yet that wasn’t incredible, it definitely lives up to the name! The pickle pizza is a must try, and the stuffed poppers (with pepperoni!) are a must order.
… more
Mitchell LeeD
Glad we gave this place a try; it instantly became our go-to for pizza if we are craving it. Great crisp crust, not doughy, good cheese and sauce, and great toppings. It’s noticeable, I’m a weirdo that digs pineapple on pizza and I can tell this places uses fresh pineapple whereas other places use canned pineapple.
… more
Rogue Smith
Today my wife and I wanted a pizza, something different than our usual Domino’s. We had seen advertisement for Midtown Pizza and decided to stop by and order a takeout. Our first reception was a locked door with a sign stating you can not enter the building. A man behind the counter wouldn’t acknowledge out presence so we went back to our car and decided to order online from their website. After multiple attempts I determined the ordering process had been disabled. At this point I called the store, still parked out in front. The employee refused to answer the phone. After two attempts to call the employee came outside to deliver a pizza to a waiting customer. I asked the employee if he could take my order and was told he could not and would not! He was the only person working and he was already making a pizza and didn’t have time to take anymore orders. He then went inside and locked the door behind him.
… more
Daniel G.
Terrible experience at every step. After trying to order three different kinds of pizza and being told they didn’t have the ingredients we settled on sausage. It arrived after an hour and a half and turned out to be the worst pizza I’ve had in a decade or more or maybe ever. I couldn’t take more than two bites. The crust was soggy, the taste was like biting into a clove of garlic, the bake was uneven. I seriously can’t get over the fact there was no other flavor than pungent garlic. I tried to call and they wouldn’t answer so after the sixth call I got through and I asked to speak to a manager and was told there wasn’t one and I couldn’t talk to anyone. They recommended I leave a comment. So here we are. I’m all for supporting local business but steer clear of this place.
… more
Ed Fuller
Just like so many people have documented – they never answer the phone anymore. Business must be good to treat customers so shabbily. Pizza is okay, but no better than other areas. Little Caesar has comparable pizza for about half as much. The extra distance (three miles) is worth it. We are done with this place. Removed the number from my phone, even. BAD, BAD customer service.
… more
Kyle
After reading the mixed reviews I had determined that I wasnt going to expect a great customer experience, but mine was actually great. Ordered online, pizza was brought out to me right away. This was great considering I was early. But then I tried to eat the pizza…At first it looked good, and even tasted ok but there was way too much cheese on it. I know a lot of people hear that and think “yay perfect” but this was a new level of too much. It was ok hot, but after 10 minutes the cheese hardened and made the pizza inedible. I am dead serious when I say that there was a solid 1.5″ brick of hardened cheese between my meat and crust. I typically dont leave bad reviews but this was just a new level of gross. The only reason I am writing at all is because this place has so much potential. If they put a normal level of cheese on it, it would have been incredible. But until then ill take my business elsewhere.
… more
Laura
Called around 5:40 pm on a Wednesday, and someone answered after several rings. I showed up 25 minutes later as requested, called them from my car, and received my pizza a minute later. Good customer service and even better pizza (spicy BBQ chicken). I’d order from here again!
… more
JAMES BREKHUS
If you want to tease your palate, this is definitely the place you order from. But don’t limit yourself to just the pizza as there is amazing salad options for those of you watching the waist line.
… more
Tim Mincey
This is my go to, for carry out or delivery! Always the best pizzas and very friendly service! Highly recommend Midtown Incredible Pizza!
… more
… View more