Black Bull House Menu – New City, NY

Type : Steak house

Location : New City, NY

Based on 80 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price

Black Bull House 10956

Address:
253 S Little Tor Rd, New City, NY 10956

Phone: (845) 708-7500

Website:

Social Profile:

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Kristin Holsapple
I know it just kind of opened but for the outrageous prices I expected more. I don’t mind paying for steak. Actually my steak was great!!! But not much else. The bread definitely did not taste like it was fresh , it almost had that I have been around for day or two.

… more

Cheryl G
Very excited to try this new place and ended up totally disappointed! Wait staff was good and attentive, but food was horrible! Lobster cocktail listed as “ 1 1/4 lb” and described by the waiter as half a lobster, well NOTHING near that! About two bites of lobster meat, for $17!! Outrageous! Told that it was a “misprint” in the menu, but no offer of a credit or additional appetizer. Stuffed mushrooms supposed to have Gorgonzola in them… NOT! Entrees tasteless. The most overpriced, expensive bad meal ever! Better to spend your hard earned money elsewhere.

… more

Dennis xxxxxx
Wanted to try out the new restaurant. Upon arrival was asked if we had a reservation (Saturday night). We didn’t and were asked to wait while the hostess checked with manager. Plenty or empty tables. She came back and we were seated. The lighting at our table was very dark and had to use a light on our phones to see the menu. Had to wait awhile for the waiter to come to our table. Ordered drinks, but they did not arrive until after our salads were served. (Waited awhile again) .

… more

Mario Acosta
Service was terrible. Waiter spilled drink on me

… more

Jonny S
They overcharge on tax (they’re charging city tax erroneously). Waiter was nice but service was super slow tonight. They’re understaffed and clearly haven’t worked out how to handle a Saturday night crowd yet. Lobster bisque and steaks were yummy. Salads were mediocre. Prices are exorbitant.

… more

Joyce Garland
I ordered pasta with a red lobster sauce since I don’t eat beef. The dish was served literally smoking hot! The chef is amazing and I learned he is from Peter Luger’s! The service was perfect.This beautiful and elegant venue can accomodate a private event upstairs, complete with a dance floor. Service was excellent.

… more

Louise Mendez
What a shame no attention to details!

… more

Jason Cohen
Went tonight with a bunch of people.

… more

Eyal Golan
Was looking forward to trying this new restaurant but too bad, not a great experience.

… more

Sandy Krolick
Under new owners. Young managers and crew from Europe. Great service. Impeccable food. New York strips were awesome as well as the clams. YOU NEED TO TRY THIS GREAT STEAKHOUSE!!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions