Laid-back, old-school bar serving pizza, fish & sandwiches in a 19th-century building. Based on 549 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
812 W Oakwood Rd, Oak Creek, WI 53154
Phone: (414) 762-9844
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2:30 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2:30 AM |
| Sunday | 9 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spt.to
Reviews
Mister Mister
First time here, it was good! The food was flavorful and came out quickly. Our waitress was friendly and checked on us frequently. I loved the decor and layout. It has an outdoor patio available for dining. They accept reservations.
… more
Terri Burdick
Food was very good. Several good dinner choices. We had parmesan tomato soup, crab legs, and Chicken Parmesan. Would recommend all of these. Service was good. Everyone was very friendly and attentive through entire meal. Very nice, rustic atmosphere. Would recommend.
… more
chris zylka
Food was great. Pizza thin crust!! Steak sandwich was great n cooked medium rare as requested. Salad was average but hit the spot. Haley our server was great. Gave recommendations n was honest about food options she had. Steak panini was flavorful n lots of mushrooms.
… more
Brandon Eddy
I didn’t eat here. I just got a beer but the overall atmosphere was nice. There is a large dining area around the corner from the bar. It looks like they are well staffed and the service was good.
… more
Linda Bury
5 of us went for Friday lunch and 4 of us ordered the haddock with potato pancakes the fish was firm but a little dry and the potato pancakes were Over done . The serving of coleslaw came with the meal but it was very small could have been a little bit bigger and a slice of Rye bread with some butter would’ve been great. the service was fantastic the other person we had with us had a seafood platter and he enjoyed it very much. The atmosphere was nice very conducive to having a visit without a state visitors don’t know how jumpy the place gets during the evening
… more
Anna Warren
Best baked fish I ever had!!! Also the best clam chowder! The service was amazing and the servers were so nice and the service was very fast.
… more
Dale Marriott
I am currently sitting at a table l, and this is our first time here. And we got seated and sat for almost 20 minutes before the server came to our table. This was after I went up and asked if we had a server outside. They asked if I was seated or seated myself. Then the server finally comes over and takes our order, and then we don’t see her again until we are almost done with our meal. The bar and seating area look great and had a great vibe. The food was really good. But our services was not good at all. That alone could make us not come back, but who knows for sure.
… more
Eric Metz
Great pizza and cheese sticks. We will be back to try many more items!
… more
Dustin Barrett
I got the fish platter and it did not disappoint. My wife got the buffalo chicken pizza and it was delicious as well. We had a couple of local beers to wash it down. The outdoor patio was well lit and heated, which was very nice. Highly recommend!
… more
Kat c
Was my first time there and have heard many nice things about The Cellar. We sat at the bar and the bartender was pleasant. Came on a Tuesday. It wasn’t very busy and our service was slow. The food took a long time to come out. Our dinner salads came out 2 bites before our dinner. It was my friends bday dinner and his tenderloin steak came out well done, when he ordered medium rare. We did not ask for it to be replaced, as we had already waited so long. We did inform the bartender it was well done and he gave us 15% off the steak dinner for the inconvenience. We appreciated that the staff acknowledged it was NOT what he ordered. I ordered the shrimp scampi. I did not taste garlic in it? Maybe I just prefer a more garlicky shrimp scampi. The breaded mushrooms appetizer was delicious. Our side salads had black olives all over them, which I did not see advertised on the menu or I would’ve asked for no olives. Gross for me. Overall, a decent experience, but nothing special. Not opposed to returning, but definitely not going out of our way to return. There are many other places I would prefer to eat at for $93 and change that our bill was.
… more
… View more