Based on 228 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2712 Eagleville Rd, West Eaton, NY 13484
Phone: (315) 684-7220
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–6 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Anthony Tartaglia
The food is always very good and I especially like the fish menu. If you like fried haddock this is the best anywhere. I order it light fried and comes out cooked perfectly.
… more
BuenasNoticiasdeIL
Unfortunately, small town failure. Ugly building that is pretty run down. I can eat at an ugly place if the food is good. The food is all deep fried mostly and simply lacking in flavor and taste. And then you see the prices…. They just are way too high for the quality of the food. So ..nope ..never again
… more
Captain Dave
Great fish fry. Keep an eye on the waitresses. Ordered 2 slices of pie after eating there for take home, $2 was added to check for take out, got home and found the waitress split one slice into two. Loser!
… more
Scott Cunningham
Let’s clarify what this place is. A locals restaurant, in BFE, in an 200 year old hotel, serving a pub-food style menu.
… more
Brittney Kelley
Fish fry on Fridays is awesome, never been disappointed with the food. Service is also always top notch.
… more
Valerie Smith
Excellent fried seafood platter, mushroom/swiss hamburgers, haddock sandwiches, fries, and sautéed squash, served by great waitstaff in a rustic setting. Loved by locals and adventurers alike! Desserts are excellent too, especially the chocolate cake – looking forward to trying the coconut cake next time. Yum!
… more
josh eastman
Overcooked chicken wings, fried pickles were soggy, and there was mold in my draft beer! 0‐10 will never return. Absolutely disgusting, clean your taps people!
… more
Matt Kent
I’ve been going here weekly with my girlfriend for over a year now, and our food has always been above and beyond. Not one complaint whatsoeverever. The waitresses, bartenders, and owner are all amazing! The only place around that can cook a steak proper. The scallops are a hidden gem too!! And I don’t even need to say anything about the wings!
… more
Jackie Anderson
Ordered the breaded Captains platter. This was the best seafood I have had. The breading was lite, the seafood was so sweet. The side order greens were as good. Our waitress was busy but attentive. I can see why it is packed most of the time. Nice job.
… more
Joe Rowlands
Good food, pleasant surprise. The only problem was the wait time from ordering to receiving meal was waaaaaaay to long. Took a good half hour to get a burger, buffalo chicken sandwich and some fries. Then when we got the meal we ordered a to go for our daughter and that was another 45 mins before it was ready. But the bacon cheeseburger that I had was perfect. My wife enjoyed her chicken and the fries. They also only serve calamari rings if that is what you like, which was how my wife loves them. Does not want tentacles.
… more
… View more