Casual spot for pan pizza with whole wheat & gluten-free crust options, plus creative toppings. Based on 709 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80521
Phone: (970) 232-9328
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 8 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Taylor Francis
Panhandlers was so delicious!! Its thick crust and generous amounts of toppings left me wanting to try every flavor! We got the Dsayuno breakfast pizza, the beggar with Chicago style sauce, and a large cheese. The breakfast pizza includes green chili, sausage, bell peppers, onions, eggs, and gooey amazing cheese! It was our overall favorite pizza. They were all incredibly delicious!! It is a little pricey, but most definitely worth it!!!!
… more
Joshua Joyce
Was hoping for a hot pizza with some spicy wings. Did not recieve either. We were served the wings first. They were good but not spicy an definitely not enough sauce. There wasn’t even a little puddle underneath the wings. Then we waited 25 more minutes for the pizza, which was expected from a fresh pizza. When we recieved it. The pan it was on wasn’t even hot/warm. The server was holding it bare handed. When we bit into it, the bottom of the crust was raw dough an the pizza was almost cold as if it sat on a counter an forgotten about. Definitely not happy. On top of it all we saw multiple customers coming in for their online orders, just to be told oh we forgot to put your pizza in. Some waited for there pizza others were just refunded. Us an 1 other couple were the only ones dinning in so they were definitely not busy. Would not recommend!
… more
Traci Bennett
Really delicious pizza! We got the breakfast pizza. It had a buttery, fluffy, nicely risen, hand made crust. High quality, with good ingredients. Fast service, friendly and helpful. So good, we will eat here again.
… more
Lee Mitchel
I used to eat here (campus west) all the time. Then I’ve moved away. Now I’m back. The sausage pizza is still the best! Sauce is so good. The recipe hasn’t changed in 30 years! Yum!
… more
Christopher Vega
Overall, our experience was great. It was pretty slow when we got here and the pizza is made from scratch so it may take a bit before you receive it. The pizza was good. I was surprised by the pricing since the google images showed a mich old photo with different prices. Regardless, it was tasty and we will most likely return for more.
… more
Gail Spinden
We love panhandlers for a special family treat. We order the large classic supreme on honey thick crust and it is the best pizza in Fort Collins. It is heafty and lasts us a few days and tastes even better as leftovers. It is the most pricey pizza you’ll buy, so we always use the Rams bucks coupon.
… more
joseph white ii
The pizza is great as is the staff working there. I also bought a shirt along with pizza because I loved everything here so much. This was the best pizza I’ve had in a while and I enjoyed the Chicago style sauce on a pepperoni pizza
… more
Todd Harding
My wife and I have loved Panhandler’s Pizza since it was located in Campus West. It is now in Midtown Common, just south of JOANN Fabric. My wife and I went to Panhandler’s Saturday night to see live music from Jalyn & the Brandt Boys, but ate an amazing pizza first. We built our own, with Chicago Style Sauce, Original Pan-Style Crust, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, and Black Olives. It was incredible, as always. Love the food. Love the staff. Can’t wait to return.
… more
Jay Snelling
Delivery pizza , not cooked full at all, doe. Doe. Doe. Doe. 1st time in Colorado loved the experience but for my first pizza. Ewwww. Make sure you reheat and rebook/recook yours
… more
Steve Pumilia
Ooof. Panhandlers is a great name because it will leave you on the street begging for change! $30 for a personal 10’ pie with 2 toppings and two soft drinks. Also it was expected to take 30 minutes, low and slow is one thing, but we are talking about a personal pizza like you would pick up at a sporting event at a stadium, for half the price. The sauce was described as original Chicago style but was essentially chopped canned tomatoes. My last complaint is that we ordered the pie as a “create your own”, which on the board showed $13.xx and $1.55 per topping and the lady at the register acted like she was doing us a favor by adding 1 topping to a premade recipe pizza but when looking over the menu that pizza started at $19.99 and we were charged for the other topping. Come to think of it the menu that is easily viewable on the order counter has no pricing on it but the board has the pricing handwritten on it further away from the customers, wonder if this is on purpose?!? Won’t be returning. If you’re looking for reasonable, better pizza check out Slyce downtown! No affiliations
… more
… View more