Lake Wanda Store Menu – Highland Lakes, NJ

Type : Deli

Location : Highland Lakes, NJ

Based on 36 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Lake Wanda Store 07422

Address:
812 Canistear Rd, Highland Lakes, NJ 07422

Phone: (973) 764-4777

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 5:30 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 5:30 AM–8 PM
Thursday 5:30 AM–8 PM
Friday 5:30 AM–8 PM
Saturday 6:30 AM–8 PM
Sunday 6:30 AM–7 PM
Monday 5:30 AM–8 PM

Menu

Pizza
Cheese Pizza $14.55
Pepperoni Roll Small $6.23
Sausage Roll Small $6.23
Chicken Parm Roll Small $6.23
Cheese Calzone $11.43
Stromboli Small $10.39
Slice $3.12
Pizza Slice With Topping $3.64
Pizza Slice Specialty $4.16
SMALL Cheese Pizza $10.39
Tuesday Special $22.88
Special Flat Bread Pizza $4.84
Meatball Roll $6.23
Small Pizza $10.39
Meatball Roll Small $6.23
White Pizza Large $16.63
White Pizza Small $12.47
Sicilian Slice $4.16
Calzone $9.35
Stromboli Large $18.71
Stromboli Small Custom $11.95
Large Pizza Dough $4.15
Small Pizza Dough $3.64
Sandwich
BOLOGNA SANDWICH $6.75
CHEESE SANDWICH $5.92
CHILD SANDWICH $4.67
HAM SANDWICH $6.75
ITALIAN SANDWICH $6.96
LIVERWURST SANDWICH $6.75
ROAST BEEF SANDWICH $8.31
TURKEY SANDWICH $7.79
CHEESE SUB $8.31
HAM SUB $9.35
SALAMI SUB $8.31
ROAST BEEF SUB $10.39
TURKEY SUB $9.14
SUB ROLL $1.56
BOLOGNA SUB $9.35
BUTTER BAGEL $2.80
CREAM CHEESE BAGEL $2.96
BUTTER ROLL $1.22
BREAKNECK SANDWICH $10.39
PEANUT BUTTER & JELLY $4.15
WAWAYANDA SANDWICH $10.39
Ham Cheese Wrap $5.71
Turkey Wrap $8.31
Ring Sandwich $31.20
Canistear AKA Italian Sub $9.35
Cold Sandwiches
The Canistear, A.K.A Italian Combo $0.00
The Wawayanda, $0.00
The Breakneck $0.00
Bologna $0.00
Cheese $0.00
Ham $0.00
Liverwurst $6.75
Roast Beef $0.00
Salami $0.00
Turkey $0.00
Chicken Salad Sandwich $9.35
Tuna Salad Sanwich $9.35
Hot Food
SM PIZZA ROLL $6.23
LARGE PIZZA $14.55
CHICKEN FINGERS $7.27
CALZONE $11.43
GARLIC KNOTS (6) $4.15
MARGERITA PIZZA $18.71
SENIOR SPECIAL $12.47
PIZZA SLICE $3.12
MOZZERELLA STICKS $7.27
SIDE SAUCE $1.04
LG DOUGH $4.16
SM DOUGH $2.59
Chicken Sandwich $6.75
Pizza Slice With Topping $3.64
Pizza Slice Specialty $4.16
Parm On Round $6.19
Tuesday Special $22.88
Sausage Egg Cheese $4.94
Cutlet $3.38
Egg Sandwiches $4.16
Chicken Parm Sandwich $10.39
Steak Egg Cheese $7.44
TAYLOR HAM EGG & CHEESE $5.98
Chicken Fingers (4) $7.27
Large Pizza Dough $4.15
Meatball Parm Sub $10.39
Jalapeno Poppers $8.31
Bakery
DONUT $1.56
HARD ROLL $0.83
PASTRY $2.86
BAGEL $1.82
BROWNIE/LINZER TART $2.86
French Baguette $3.12
MIAMI ONION ROLL $1.82
SUB ROLL $1.56
LG ITALIAN BREAD $3.90
RYE/PUMPERNKL $4.98
Smiley Cookie $1.56
Butter Bagel $2.44
Cream Cheese Bagel $2.96
Butter Roll $1.46
Strudel Stick $1.56
Muffin $2.86
Loose Candy $0.26
Sides N Such
Mozarella Sticks(6) $6.23
Jalapeno Poppers(6) $6.23
Side Of Sauce 8 Oz $1.04
Topping On Slice $1.04
Chicken Fingers (4) $7.27
Double Crust On Large Pie $4.16
Double Crust On Small Pie $2.08
Large Pizza Dough $4.15
Small Pizza Dough $3.64
Sandwiches Hot & Cold
The Canistear Sandwich $6.75
The Wawayanda Sandwich $6.75
The Breakneck Sandwich $6.75
Meatball Parm Sandwich $10.29
Cheese Sandwich $5.92
Ham Sandwich $6.75
Liverwurst Sandwich $6.75
Roast Beef Sandwich $8.31
Salami Sandwich $6.75
Turkey Sandwich $7.79
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich $7.79
Taylor Ham, Egg And Cheese $5.98
Becon Egg And Cheese $4.94
Chicken Parm Sandwich Rr $7.79
Ham Sub $9.35
Chicken Parm Sub $10.39
Eggplant Parm Sand RR $7.27
Eggplant Parm Sub $9.35
Deli
Thumans Bacon $10.39

… View more

Reviews

Gillian Champagne
The staff is so friendly. The store is kept very clean. View of the lake.

… more

Jonathan Nunez
Fires employees just hired on , ” for being on phone too much “. Yet keeps employees who show up late 2 hrs past their shift , who are suppose to change shifts with someone who has been there since 5 a.m. Also rents out an apartment above the store to someone who can’t even pay rent. But fires a new hire for their phone. The owner plays favorites and only wants those he can minipulate under his employment. Do NOT support this bigot.

… more

Jason Peranio
Best Italian sub I have ever had hands down

… more

A F
Great Store! Excellent Service! Ken the owner, Debbie and the rest of the staff always greet you warmly great people all around. Beautiful view of lake from inside! Cute dock outside perfect for sunrise pics! The perfect stop when you don’t want to be bothered going to a supermarket. Love it! Wouldn’t trade them for anything!!

… more

Breezy
Cute store with essentials, food, beer, etc for sale. Their empanadas are delicious (when they have them – they sell out quickly). And I love the extra hot, hot sauce – sooo good. Decent beer selection, however, their beer is not in coolers so it’s not convenient for same-day drinking. Nice view out the back of Lake Wanda too.

… more

Stu P
Wow, I just tried the new Tacos at Lake Wanda deli and it was delicious. It was everything I was looking for in a taco. Good job. Definitely be back

… more

Janine “J9 rhymes with canine!” Hummel
Lake Wanda Store chicken salad had cranberries, light seasoning, I think I tasted an almond or two, celery and onion. I am not one to bother writing food reviews, but this place was a shocker, plus it was super reasonable. ~ its cashiers are funny, pleasant, and kind. Quirky and fun place <3! Go here! You'll find a treasure...or two!

… more

Jessica DeBenedetto
I love the Wanda store. I’ve been going there for years. Great service and far better food than other stores on the mountain.

… more

Russell Goldberg
I just love the Lake Wanda store been going since im a kid when i moved back i was glad to see its still there but bigger and better. I love the staff they are always helpful and nice

… more

Keota
Honestly best pizza in Vernon right now. Love the vibes in there. The owner was always a nice dude, too, from what I remember.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions