Based on 230 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3231 McHenry Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45211
Phone: (513) 662-3323
Hours
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Karen Lawley
I have driven by this restaurant for many years, and finally decided to stop in. I ordered a pizza on my way from work and it was ready when I got there. If only, they could bottle the wonderful smell coming out of their kitchen! The pizza was fabulous! It’s the kind of neighborhood pizza place, where the toppings aren’t weighed. The cheese was gooey and the meats were yummy! We all really enjoyed the meat topper pizza and can’t wait to make it a regular stop!! The staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Scarlato’s, I’m sorry it took me so long to stop by!!! See you next week!
… more
Rick Doherty
Scarlato’s Meat Topper Pizza is delicious. Whenever I find myself on the Westside and hungry I pick one up. I prefer it over the big local pizzeria chain. The stone fired crust and generous toppings makes all the difference. Get you some !
… more
Cassandra Roberson
Man they brought the chicken wings back and I couldn’t be more happier!! I just got 2 of they( to me) the best fish hoagies in Cincinnati and some wings and fries and they were hot and fresh and in less than 30 minutes! Thanks y’all!!! ( repeat customer)
… more
Gurlbuttafly kidd
Was really excited to return to this establishment after almost 27years. Ordered a pizza and got home, only to find that the crust was 90% burned. Called back and spoke with a lady that took my phone number and complaint and was told the owner would return my call. I waited for about 45 minutes and decided to take the food back. My sister had also ordered the same and hers was burnt as well but they ate around the “bad” parts and also it wasn’t as severely burned as mine. When I arrived, a gentleman at the window asked why I was returning and asked the guys in the back “you burning pizza?” The person that responded just happened to be the owner and immediately went in defensive mode saying “ It’s not burnt by any standards”
… more
Cullen Cook
Had the baked royal hoagie and bacon cheese fries and it was litterly the best thing ive eatin in awhile .Food is really good. Everything is cook to order meaning nothing just sits and gets cold or old. The people are very friendly I’ve witnessed them doing different good deeds for the community. Safe to say I’ll be going here for many more years to come
… more
Latisha Gause
I had steak & cheese hoagie? That was a burger shaped like a steak patty. ( i dnt like hoagies if thats what they are??) Gross …but I hear the pizza is awesome so I won’t give up on them that quick..but the service was fast, the staff was friendly and a joy. They made the experience worth another try!!!
… more
Matt Stephans
This place is amazing . The food is all cook to order meaning its always fresh and the people that work here are extremely friendly. My favorite is the Meat topper pizza and be sure to try the new triple chocolate brownies . Anyone leaving bad comments on here is clearly just hating … thanks scarlatos for serving the Westside. We all know many won’t
… more
Denise Baughman
Our pizza was wonderful! You have a young man named Matt working there and he definitely knows how to make a delicious pizza! Will definitely be back for more yummy food!
… more
Butterfly24 Stars
Someone i know who was placing two orders yesterday evening to order a steak hoagie and 4 chicken tenders and the worker (male) who works there and was asking someone i know what they wanted on their steak hoagie on mushrooom sauce, provolone cheese, onions and pickles and french fries and a coleslaw and a worker (male) said to someone i know that “Oh sir or ma and we don’t had a coleslaw until around summer or fall and person i know and said ok and a worker (male) added up the register and let the person i know that it will cost 27 darn dollars of worth of food and is almost 30 darn dollars worth of food and they lost their darn minds. And person i know told the worker (male) to take off the chicken tenders meal off the register. How they went from 9 dollars to 15 dollards for steak hoagie and chicken tenders from 9 dollards to 15 dollards wow. And the worker (male) said it will take 45 minutes for a another worker to delivery And person call back in 4 or 5 minutes to cancel the order and a delivery service and because someone has to take the bus.
… more
Ariel Daniels
I have been looking forward after driving past them through out the years and finally took the leap! Let’s just say they did not disappoint! The hoagies were amazing. The chicken tender on bun has by far my favorite, but the meatball and royal (yes I ordered 3 hoagie and no I have no regrets) did not fall short! Pizza and customer service were on 10. When I arrived there were only 2 people running the show and my jaw and stomach were on the floor I can’t wait to go back!
… more
… View more