Family run and operated, the “Boss,” Mimmo Gambino, opened the doors of Casa Rustia in Smithtown, NY, in 1985. In the past, he had created many fine-dining establishments in New York City. Born and raised in a “small town you’ve never heard of in Palermo, Italy,” as Mimmo Gambino used to say, Mimmo came to New York City to purse the American dream. Focusing on his Sicilan upbringing, he instilled a new culture to the recipes that we still use today.
Old-world Italian cuisine is the draw at this upscale ristorante with rustic accents & fireplace. Based on 303 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
175 W Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787
Phone: (631) 265-9265
Website: http://casarusticali.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
12–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
12–9 PM |
| Thursday |
12–9 PM |
| Friday |
12–9 PM |
| Saturday |
12–9 PM |
| Sunday |
12–9 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Pat B
I haven’t been here in years. It was a great choice! Started with the perfect Martini. Excellent meal! I had the bruschetta and it was fresh and perfectly toasted. I also had the beets salad and it was huge. Fried calamari was cooked to perfection! I had the branzini and it was delicious. My favorite was the mushroom risotto! Only drawback was we didn’t have room for dessert!!!
… more
Val C
Food was delicious, and service was great.
… more
PJ Cammarata
Benny is a great host..Lobster flambe w/ brandy is fantastic.. they take all the meat out of the shell so you don’t have to struggle …Cappellini Gino with jumbo shrimp and crab meat Fradiavlo excellent.. it’s a hidden gem! Now one of our favorites!!
… more
Lorraine Rhodes
What an unbelievable meal we had for a friends birthday, everything was delicious. We ordered appetizers, salads, entrees and desserts, everyone raved about how good their meal was. Too many people to give examples of each dish, but we can’t wait to go back!
… more
Brett Bar
A very high 4 rating, things are really here
… more
Bill M
Great little spot. Went for lunch. Had a fantastic veal chop! I don’t eat lobster but people rave about it. Meatballs are on point.
… more
Eric Slone
Went here yesterday for a business event and the food was delicious! Probably one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever went to. The place is beautiful, service is excellent, and would definitely go back.
… more
Gini Maurici
I have been going to Casa Rustica, for over 20 years. It is my Favorite local restaurant. I’ve have never been disappointed. Their Lobster dish, is the best ever. And the service is impeccable.
… more
Gappsi Giuseppe Abbrancati
if you like lobster? this is the only place on long island that i know its worth going to! great services, food and Atmosphere!
… more
Dawn Golan
Food and service was very good. We would go back. Adele our waiter was great.
… more
… View more
