An array of classic & creative pizzas, pastas, & Italian favorites in an easygoing setting. Based on 150 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1430 N Green St I, Brownsburg, IN 46112
Phone: (317) 858-2469
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Matt
I had just arrived in town, checked in to my hotel, and was looking for dinner. I had been on the road for a week already, and was craving some “good” pizza. When I think of “good” pizza, I avoid chains. I was looking for a small local joint. I checked google maps and found Papa’s nearby. Decided to give it a try! WOW! Great call. This is exactly what I was looking for. I only had pizza, which was amazing, but they have all sorts of Italian food, and the dishes I saw coming out looked delicious as well. The service was excellent, and the food was amazing. Highly recommend!
… more
Aric Acius
We ordered take out (no dine in right now) had 2 calzones and pepperoni bread sticks, very good and on time. They even refunded us for an ordering mistake on our part online.
… more
Mackenzie Thada
New favorite Brownsburg pizza joint. I’m super picky about crust and this crust was PERFECT! Toppings seemed like better quality than the other local competitors in my opinion. Salad was fresh and carbonara pasta was delicious. We tried the bourbon wings too and the flavor was amazing though the wings were slightly tough/over cooked maybe. Didn’t stop us from devouring them though. We will keep coming back to try more things!
… more
Billy Green
Everything we ordered was phenomenal. Italian sub, fettuccine Alfredo, spaghetti and meatballs, super fresh salad, killer breadsticks and dipping sauces. We will definitely get takeout here again.
… more
Ben Krieger
We drive by this exit frequently and read the reviews that looked great. So, we dutifully looked up their hours on Google to not stop at a closed place, but much to our surprise, the place is closed despite saying it was open on Google.. information that all businesses control and update in 20 seconds. If would be helpful for potential customers to have a chance to try you out… very frustrating..
… more
C Lunde
Stopped nearby on a roadtrip through town, looking for good food that was from a family run place. This place was EXACTLY what we were looking for. Called ahead our order and parking lot picked up. Had pink sauce penne, kids spaghetti and meatball and their special sauce Amatriciana. Yum! Size portions were perfect…used the garlic bread to get every bit of that sauce.
… more
Deborah Flowers
Absolutely delicious! The salad was cold and the lettuce was crisp! The pizza was hot and the crust was delicious. We had several people in our group, many of whom ordered pasta dishes and they looked divine! The service was excellent! The once issue I have is they are really close to my house – way too easy to stop in to try all their different dishes!
… more
Ame Lahiff
This is my hidden gem of pizza places! And they also have great pasta dinners as well, and their prices are very modest especially for the portions and quality of the food! The owner is a very kind and friendly person and will go out of his way to make sure you’re satisfied, as he has done some pretty cool things for me in the past and recently I was craving a slice of Heaven and I was sorry to see they were not open due to the state of our living situation with the virus and such! But as soon as I get the first opportunity you’d better believe I will be there for my slice and to see my friend! Thank you for the best of service and warm atmosphere you offer!
… more
Ame Lahiff
I wish they were open again so I could eat inside because I drive a little further for their food than I would absolutely any other Italian spot for authentic food within 20 miles and when people say that they had a bad experience there then I ask them why and 9 out of 10 times it’s always because they were probably extremely busy and that person wasn’t able to get over themselves! I know the people that own this place so therefore I happen also to know they make things right for any difficulty they brought about on their end so move on and that’s just more for people like me who genuinely appreciate the people, the business, and for heavens sake calm down it’s worth it the PIZZA is the best ! Thank you Papa’s for being the best kept secret in the Burg! I appreciate you
… more
Ashley Ricciardi
We are becoming regulars at this place! It’s a family owned business with amazing Italian food! I’ve yet to have a meal there that I didn’t enjoy. The kids love the pizza, which you can order and have delivered! Service is excellent! Right off the interstate tucked in a little strip. Even if you have to venture out a bit, it’s an easy drive that you won’t be sorry you made! Just be aware, they’re closed Mondays.
… more
… View more