Based on 85 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
3 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Phone: (631) 749-9292
Website: https://www.shelterislandslice.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eli Davidoff
If you want excellent pizza, no need to look further. This pizza has been favorite ever since I was a little kid, and I lived in new haven Connecticut which supposedly has the best pizza in America, but shelter island slice beats them over and over again because of their ever changing menu and awesome staff. Good vibes and great pizza, what more can you ask for.
… more
Chris
Got the chicken bacon ranch and added some marinara at the pizza makers suggestion… AMAZING. Super cool staff and the pizza is top notch. Thanks guys!
… more
Aunt Smith
Not sure how Slice has stayed in business. I have never been so grossed out in my life. Everyone behind the counter is dripping with sweat and miserable. I gave my order to more than one person before it was put through. My pizza came out so overcooked, how could they serve it like that? The menu says ‘3 meatballs,’ but I only got 2, and it doesn’t really matter as they were inedible. One bite, and I threw them out.
… more
moses burdon
Frankie still makes the best pizza in the area by far.
… more
JeanMarie Reinke
The pizza is excellent and they are BUSY, so I overlook the owner’s weirdly aggressive attitude towards anyone ordering or picking up. “ WHAT DO YOU WANT?????” Uh my pizza I’m paying you for. It is good though.. But he could chill.
… more
Sassy JD
The person behind the counter is adding Parmesan cheese to everybody’s pizza with an unwashed hand touching money and then touching food just so gross! They need to learn how to wash their hands and serve food was gross
… more
Patricia Curtis
The staff are nice and friendly and capable and make a great pizza. I look forward to going back as soon as the pizza has been eaten!
… more
Leanne L
Really good pizza. Owner super friendly. Loved it.
… more
Nycnyc
First time ordering a pie from here. Perfect pizza. Great sauce, not too much crust, perfectly cooked. Will be ordering again.
… more
marien vuik
Best pizza ever.
… more
… View more