Based on 136 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
Address:
1250 Sussex Turnpike, Randolph, NJ 07869
Phone: (973) 933-2531
Website: https://www.mammacaterinamenu.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
AM Reing
My review is not from today, however it is based on our years’ experience w this local pizzeria. I cannot figure out what’s happened that they’ve been closed recently, but hopefully they will reopen soon. We miss their mama’s pizza! The BEST pizza in the area!
… more
Joshua Schroeder
Absolutely wild. The lack of customer service is borderline sociopathic. The ***** made my kids uncomfortable about asking for ranch, acting like she’s in the pizza business and never heard of such a thing.
… more
Chuck Mound
2.5 stars. You can tell that they tried to use every bit of the dough as possible because of how the middle of the slice was really runny. The sauce was not tasty, cheese was ok and the crust most not memorable. Just an average slice for a town pizzeria. Customer Service was non existent. First met with a sign telling you that you will be hit with a fee if you choose to use a credit card. Felt like I was at an ATM debating the transaction because of the service fees. I 100 percent agree that the Credit Card Companies are out of control with fees, just look at Go Fund Me and their scam, but go to an all Cash Business then. Just leaves a bad taste before even having any food. Anyway, our experience for the Pizza Hunters App was middle of the pack. See how they do in the Specialty Pizza Round.
… more
Debra Knaus
Ordered a half pan of Lasagna. Very disappointed, hardy no meat and the only cheese was on top. All noodles and sauce. Will not order lasagna again. I will say that their pizza is good.
… more
Karina B
I ordered calamari and I literally counted 19 pieces including 3 little ones. I never felt so cheated and over priced. If they want to keep their business open they shouldn’t cut corners . Restaurants NYC do better than this and they have it harder, since they have close again. Never going to order calamari from here. RIP OFF … run and save your money- how is this suppose to be enough for the family?! They didn’t even deserve a star!
… more
freeman1027
Everything was nice , 4 stars is for the pizza, a little underedone. But tasted great.
… more
Edwin
This place never disappoints me the grilled chicken sandwich is always delicious!!
… more
David Branch
My favorite. Frank and Alex are always warm and welcoming. Great chicken rolls, thin pizza, and awesome baked ziti with ricotta cheese. I am there 3x a week for takeout and have never had a bad meal.
… more
John Jones
I got about 8 pieces of calamari for like $13 and ended up paying more for 4 slices of pizza than a whole pie! I don’t like this place. There are so many better options in town that won’t cheat you on the calamari portion or overcharge you. I spoke to the owner and he just defended himself. He offered nothing other than “prices have gone up blah blah blah and I’ll talk to my cook about the calamari”. What does that get me? Not going back and won’t recommend.
… more
Jim M
Went there tonight , 2 of us an a 2 year old. Walked in, 2 workers were sitting at a table doing nothing, a guy and a girl. Didn’t get up, didn’t say a word to us, we sat down and waited a minute, nobody came to the table. Went and got the high chair on my own. Had to order at the counter and get my own food when it was done. Nobody basically said a word to us. This is customer service? Place was empty, maybe that’s why.
… more
… View more