5 Thumbs BBQ Menu – Indianapolis, IN

Type : Barbecue restaurant

Location : Indianapolis, IN

Based on 24 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

5 Thumbs BBQ 46268

Address:
4320 W 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268

Phone: (463) 276-8447

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Sunday Closed
Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed
Tuesday 11 AM–3 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–3 PM
Thursday 11 AM–3 PM
Friday 11 AM–3 PM
Saturday Closed

Menu

Pork
Full Rack Of Ribs
8 St Louis style smoked ribs. Includes sauce on the side
$25.00
Half Rack Of Ribs
4 St Louis style smoked ribs. Includes sauce on the side
$14.00
1 Lb Pulled Pork
1 pound of smoked pulled pork. Includes sauce on the side
$15.00
1/2 LB Pulled Pork Sandwich
1/2 lb smoked pulled pork sandwich. Includes sauce on the side
$8.50
1/2 Lb Pulled Pork
1/2 pound of smoked pulled pork. Includes sauce on the side
$8.50
Large Rib Tips
Approx 1 lb serving of smoked rib tips
$13.50
1/4 LB Pulled Pork Sandwich
1/4 lb smoked pulled pork sandwich. Includes sauce on the side
$5.50
Small Rib Tips
Approx 10oz serving of smoked rib tips
$9.50
Smoked Brat
Smoked Pork Bratwurst
$6.00
Beef
1/2 Lb Burnt Ends
1/2 lb brisket burnt ends
$16.00
1 Lb Burnt Ends
1 lb brisket burnt ends
$30.00
Snack Size Burnt Ends
4 oz brisket burnt ends
$9.00
Chicken
1/2 LB Smoked Chopped Chicken
1/2 Pound Smoked Chopped Chicken
$8.50
1LB Smoked Chopped Chicken
1 LB Smoked Chopped Chicken
$15.00
Smoked Chopped Chicken Sandwich
1/2 LB Smoked Chopped Chicken Sandwich
$8.50
8 Smoked Wings $12.00
1/4LB Chopped Chicken Sandwich
1/2 LB Smoked Chopped Chicken Sandwich
$5.50
Sandwiches
1/4 LB Pulled Pork Sandwich
1/4 LB Pulled Pork Sandwich. Includes sauce on the side
$5.50
1/2 LB Pulled Pork Sandwich
1/2 LB Pulled Pork Sandwich. Includes sauce on the side
$8.50
Sides
Coleslaw
6 oz serving of coleslaw
$2.25
Mac And Cheese
6 oz serving of mac and cheese
$2.25
Cornbread
Slice of cornbread
$1.25
Smoked Sweet Corn
6oz of Smoked Sweet Corn
$2.25
Potato Salad
6oz Serving of Potato Salad
$2.25
Green Beans With Bacon
6oz Serving of Green Beans With Bits of Bacon
$2.25
Chips & Drinks
Drinks $1.25
Bag Of Chips $1.25

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Matt Muller
Brisket was good. May be better if you chopped it for sandwiches. Had good flavor. Would have liked a variety of choices for bbq sauces instead of just the one served with meal. Side of Mac and cheese reminded me of just some Kraft Mac and cheese and definitely can be improved. Would eat the brisket again, would prefer it to be a little more juicy and tender next time but not bad.

… more

R “killerrazzmazz” Wilson
Went here for lunch with my girlfriend the other day during work and I tried the burnt brisket ends with side of mac. They were delicious. Girlfriend got a pork sandwich and liked it as well. She tried a piece of my brisket and love it as well. Chicken was sold out that whole day unfortunately due to a large order but will likely be back to try more items. Not expensive here but not cheap either but you pay for good BBQ. Definitely come give this place a try if you’re into good BBQ.

… more

Kellie Jones
I purchased a large rib tip and received 4 huge chunks of unseasoned meat. It could’ve used at least some salt and pepper to help the flavor of the bland meat. Tips are cut in huge chunks, no flavor nor barbecue sauce on meat. So if you like huge chunks of unflavored meat this is the place for you. I always pass by this place so I decided to give them a try. Very disappointing and I will never waste money going back to this place!

… more

Daryl Stall
Fresh Smoked Daily. Warm welcome, friendly conversation. Fabulous BBQ. Nice dinning area. You won’t be disappointed. 5 stars all the way!

… more

Will Christians
Ordered delivery and it arrived right when I asked. Pork was good. Chicken was okay. But the rib tips and burnt ends were fantastic. Some how had some leftover the next day and damn if they weren’t just as good.

… more

Ryan Thomas
Stopped by for lunch today. Orders a brisket sandwich and coleslaw. The meat tasted like sanitizer. It was very off putting. The coleslaw was excellent and the guys working were nice but that brisket was awful.

… more

Matt Kolb
The food was great! This is my second time stopping by, and both times were excellent. I had the brisket sandwich, bbq beans & potato salad. The brisket sandwich was fantastic, as was the potato salad. The beans were a little “runny” for my tastes, but the flavor was good, so no complaints. The sauce on the side was a perfect pairing with the sandwich. Will be adding this place to my regular lunch rotation for sure!

… more

Kendal Bennett
We ordered the burnt ends and the rib tips. BB’s Mac and cheese and potato salad. Overall this was the absolute worst tasting food I have ever had. Both meats were so over cooked or days old it was pathetic. We even picked up at 11:30 and they open at 11:30. Channel 8 made a mistake promoting this business. Don’t believe everything you see advertised on T.V .

… more

Jordan Walters
I have been trying to get over here for a while, and I’m glad I did. Brisket is on point, and I’m glad they didn’t cover it in sauce. Sauce hides a lot of flaws and there weren’t any with the brisket, it was awesome.

… more

Suzy Hardwick
Best beef brisket ever! Anxious to try the ribs – photos looked great (not over cooked) – next time. Only complaint? So so sauce & sides. But GO for the star of the lunch…the meat!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions