Fast and Casual New York Style Pizza Parlor. We offer a variety of Pizzas, Calzones, Hot Plates, Appetizers, Beer and Wine. Our establishment offers dine in, take out as well as delivery (from partners). For more menu information call or visit our website.
Unassuming, family-run pizzeria doling out slices & pies along with subs, pasta dishes & appetizers. Based on 563 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
16995 W Greenway Rd #104, Surprise, AZ 85388
Phone: (623) 544-3332
Website: http://www.1brotherspizza.com/
Hours
| Friday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
EmilyisHappy
Happened on this place one evening. The crispy crust is great 5 stars. Seems stone fired of sorts. They have just a base cheese pizza, and you can add an array of toppings. It was yummy but not the best I have ever had. Price isn’t bad. Overall, it was an okay experience, especially for a local joint. Will try to come back and try their white pizza. Seems unique to this place.
Blerta E
This is my favorite pizza place ever. This is my favorite spot to go to. I get their pizza and wings every week. The food is so good and it is at a good price too!! The staff are very friendly and very nice people. They have such great customer service. I recommend you try this place asap. It is consistently good! I recommend you definitely try it, you will not regret it!!
Whiskey Bravo
Like an idiot, I ordered an extra large pizza online thinking I was ordering from this location on Greenway. I get there, and no pizza. I called Slice to find out where the order went and when the owner of this location saw my defeated posture, waved me over and said “I make you one, half price”, and graciously put his hand on his heart and bowed. I doubled the $10 charge with a tip and it was the best, freshest pizza experience I’ve had in long time. The owner, who speaks broken English with an Italian accent is the nicest man, prides himself for having great prices, and I intend on being the most loyal customer he has. Super!
Katarina Springer
From someone who is from New York, this pizza is the best I have found in Arizona! Not to mention, we have never had an issue with our order. Always delicious and always on time! The staffing they have are such sweet people. It feels as if I were back home in my small town pizza shop. I am a one-a-week customer!
Judy Davis
This pizza was amazing. Will definitely be back. They really put a lot of toppings on the meat pizza. Wings were good and antipasto salad was loaded also, more topping than lettuce. Very friendly also.
Sam A
The owner of this place is awesome. Really takes care of his customers. I’m from Chicago so can’t give pizza 5 stars because I’m bious. But it’s really good. Good drink specials (beer and wine) and you can dine in. Definitely coming back.
Mylan Fernandez
First experience wasn’t the best. Decided to give them another shot. Food was OKAY at best.. but I ordered an XL and a L pizza with 20 wings. The Pizza’s were the same exact size and the wings were the size of my thumb, LITERALLY.
Lea Hill
We just Love the place! It’s like home! Like family!! We have been going there since our youngest was 3 years old….Mira is our absolute favorite and the food is more than #1 in my book and always has been. Today we as a family decided to celebrate our youngest son’s graduation from high school there and we had the best experience, we even brought our whole family and everyone raves about the food!
Jeff Eavenson
When I’m craving a NY style pizza, #1 Brothers is my go to. Great crust and sauce. They are quick with preparing my order which I usually get for pick up. The staff is friendly and appreciative of the patronage.
Julie Shelton-Mollo
Great pizza, calzones, wings, breads, sauce and salads! We go at least 2 times a week. Bruno and his dad are always smiling and a joy to see.
… View more